diff --git a/.claude/docs/analysis/CI_FAILURES_2024-11-21.md b/.claude/docs/analysis/CI_FAILURES_2024-11-21.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..01fa1f8af4 --- /dev/null +++ b/.claude/docs/analysis/CI_FAILURES_2024-11-21.md @@ -0,0 +1,523 @@ +# CI Failure Analysis - Branch justin808/monorepo-completion + +**Date**: 2025-11-21 +**PR**: #2069 +**Analyst**: Claude Code Review +**Status**: πŸ”΄ NOT READY TO MERGE - Multiple Test Failures + +--- + +## ⚠️ CRITICAL DISCLAIMER + +**This analysis contains UNTESTED hypotheses only.** + +**Environment**: Analysis performed in Conductor isolated workspace with limited capabilities: + +- ❌ Cannot run full Rails application +- ❌ Cannot execute integration tests +- ❌ Cannot test webpack build pipeline +- ❌ Cannot verify fixes against actual failing tests +- βœ… Can analyze CI logs and source code +- βœ… Can identify suspicious commits +- βœ… Can provide reproduction steps + +**What this means**: + +- All "fixes" below are **hypotheses that MUST be tested locally** +- Do NOT assume any proposed fix will work without verification +- All investigation is based on log analysis and code inspection only +- Actual root causes may differ from analysis after local testing + +**Before implementing any fix**: Test it locally in the actual React on Rails repository first. + +--- + +## Executive Summary + +**All tests PASSED on merge base** (`5e033c716` - v16.2.0.beta.12) βœ… +**Current Status**: 3 test suites FAILING, 1 test suite HUNG (80+ minutes) + +This is a **REGRESSION** introduced by changes in this branch related to: + +1. Monorepo restructuring (Phase 5: Pro Node Renderer extraction) +2. `buildConsoleReplay` parameter order fix +3. Workspace dependency changes + +--- + +## Failing Test Suites + +### 1. Integration Tests - JavaScript Asset Loading ❌ + +**Configurations**: Both `minimum` (Ruby 3.2, Node 20) and `latest` (Ruby 3.4, Node 22) +**Duration**: Failed after 2m26s - 2m36s +**Failed Examples**: 21 failures + +#### Error Pattern + +```text +Uncaught SyntaxError: Unexpected token '<' +``` + +At line numbers: 167, 199, 211, 226, 239, 253, 267, 274 in HTML pages + +#### Root Cause Analysis + +JavaScript files returning HTML (404 pages) instead of JavaScript code. The browser attempts to execute HTML as JavaScript, causing syntax errors. + +**Evidence**: + +- βœ… Webpack bundles restored from cache successfully +- βœ… `yarn install` completes without errors +- βœ… Some webpack files load correctly (e.g., `/webpack/test/js/890.js`) +- ❌ Most component-specific bundles fail to load + +**What This Means**: +The webpack infrastructure partially works, but specific bundles aren't being generated or served correctly. This suggests: + +1. Build artifacts may not be created during `yarn install` (prepare scripts) +2. Asset paths may be incorrect after monorepo restructuring +3. Rails may be looking for bundles in the wrong location + +#### Sample Failing Tests + +```text +Pages/Index when rendering All in one page + with Server Rendered/Cached React/Redux Component + βœ— is expected to have visible css "div#ReduxApp-react-component-0" + βœ— changes name in message according to input + with Server Rendered/Cached React Component Without Redux + βœ— is expected to have visible css "div#HelloWorld-react-component-1" + βœ— changes name in message according to input + with Simple Client Rendered Component + βœ— is expected to have visible css "div#HelloWorldApp-react-component-2" + βœ— changes name in message according to input +``` + +**Total Impact**: All React component rendering tests fail + +--- + +### 2. Pro Node Renderer Tests - Console Replay Format ❌ + +**Configuration**: Ruby 3.3.7 +**Duration**: Failed after 4m58s +**Failed Examples**: 1 failure + +#### Error Details + +```ruby +Failure/Error: expect(script_line).to eq(expected_line) + + expected: "console.log.apply(console, [\"[SERVER] RENDERED ReduxSharedStoreApp to dom node with id: ReduxSharedStoreApp-react-component-0\"]);" + got: "