Skip to content

Commit 0109856

Browse files
carloseberhardtclaude
carloseberhardt
and
claude
authored
fix: remove TODO comments and dead code (resolves #64) (#105)
Clean up codebase by removing all TODO/FIXME comments and commented-out code blocks to improve maintainability and code quality. Changes: - Remove 11 TODO comments across import commands, CLI service, and tests - Remove ~50 lines of dead code including unused spawnProcess method - Convert remaining TODOs to descriptive comments with issue references - Add architecture analysis documentation All 227 tests continue to pass after cleanup. 🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.ai/code) Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent e4c7bfe commit 0109856

File tree

10 files changed

+270
-116
lines changed

10 files changed

+270
-116
lines changed

‎docs/architecture-analysis.md‎

Lines changed: 267 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,267 @@
1+
# Architecture Analysis & Improvement Recommendations
2+
3+
*Generated: January 2025*
4+
5+
## Executive Summary
6+
7+
The VSCode StepZen extension demonstrates **excellent architectural implementation** that largely exceeds the documented architecture. The codebase follows solid patterns with comprehensive service registry, proper error handling, and extensive testing. The main gaps are documentation updates rather than implementation issues.
8+
9+
**Overall Assessment: 🟢 EXCELLENT** - Implementation surpasses documentation in most areas.
10+
11+
## Architecture Compliance Analysis
12+
13+
### ✅ Fully Implemented Components
14+
15+
#### 1. Service Registry Pattern
16+
- **Status**: Fully implemented with 6 services (vs 4 documented)
17+
- **Compliance**: Exceeds documentation
18+
- **Services**:
19+
- ✅ `StepzenCliService` (documented)
20+
- ✅ `Logger` (documented)
21+
- ✅ `ProjectResolver` (documented)
22+
- ✅ `SchemaIndexService` (documented)
23+
- ❌ `RequestService` (implemented but not documented)
24+
- ❌ `ImportService` (implemented but not documented)
25+
26+
#### 2. Error Handling System
27+
- **Status**: Perfectly implemented
28+
- **Compliance**: Exactly matches documentation
29+
- **Hierarchy**: `StepZenError` → `CliError`, `NetworkError`, `ValidationError`
30+
- **Handler**: Central error normalization with user notifications
31+
32+
#### 3. Command Implementation
33+
- **Status**: 16 commands implemented (vs basic set documented)
34+
- **Compliance**: Exceeds documentation
35+
- **Pattern**: All commands follow documented patterns with workspace trust checks, validation, and error handling
36+
37+
#### 4. Testing Strategy
38+
- **Status**: Comprehensive implementation
39+
- **Compliance**: Exceeds documentation
40+
- **Coverage**: Unit tests, integration tests, service mocking, test utilities
41+
42+
### 🔍 Architecture Gaps & Inconsistencies
43+
44+
#### Minor Documentation Gaps
45+
46+
1. **Service Registry Documentation Mismatch**
47+
- **Issue**: Documentation shows 4 services, implementation has 6
48+
- **Impact**: Low - implementation is more complete
49+
- **Recommendation**: Update documentation to include `RequestService` and `ImportService`
50+
51+
2. **Missing Test Utility**
52+
- **Issue**: Documentation mentions `createMockServiceRegistry()` but it's not implemented
53+
- **Impact**: Low - existing mock utilities are sufficient
54+
- **Recommendation**: Either implement the utility or remove from documentation
55+
56+
3. **Schema Processing Layer Organization**
57+
- **Issue**: Services are in `services/schema/` rather than top-level as documented
58+
- **Impact**: None - current organization is better
59+
- **Recommendation**: Update documentation to reflect actual organization
60+
61+
## Architectural Strengths
62+
63+
### 1. Service Registry Excellence
64+
```typescript
65+
// Actual implementation is more robust than documented
66+
export interface ServiceRegistry {
67+
cli: StepzenCliService;
68+
logger: Logger;
69+
projectResolver: ProjectResolver;
70+
schemaIndex: SchemaIndexService;
71+
request: RequestService; // 🆕 Not in docs
72+
import: ImportService; // 🆕 Not in docs
73+
}
74+
```
75+
76+
**Testing Support:**
77+
- ✅ `overrideServices()` - Individual service mocking
78+
- ✅ `resetServices()` - Service restoration
79+
- ✅ `setMockServices()` - Full registry replacement
80+
- ✅ Comprehensive test coverage
81+
82+
### 2. Command Pattern Consistency
83+
All 16 commands follow the documented pattern:
84+
```typescript
85+
export async function commandName() {
86+
// 1. Workspace trust check
87+
if (!vscode.workspace.isTrusted) { return; }
88+
89+
// 2. Precondition validation
90+
if (!precondition) { showError(); return; }
91+
92+
// 3. Service usage with error handling
93+
try {
94+
services.logger.info("Command started");
95+
// Implementation
96+
} catch (err) {
97+
handleError(err);
98+
}
99+
}
100+
```
101+
102+
### 3. Error Handling Robustness
103+
- **Hierarchical**: Clear error type hierarchy
104+
- **Centralized**: Single error handler with normalization
105+
- **User-Friendly**: Consistent notifications with "Show Logs" action
106+
- **Developer-Friendly**: Full context logging
107+
108+
### 4. Schema Processing Architecture
109+
```
110+
src/services/schema/
111+
├── indexer.ts # Symbol indexing & location tracking
112+
├── linker.ts # SDL traversal & file linking
113+
└── parser.ts # GraphQL AST utilities
114+
```
115+
- **Better Organization**: More logical than documented flat structure
116+
- **Clear Separation**: Each component has distinct responsibility
117+
118+
## Improvement Recommendations
119+
120+
### 🔴 High Priority (Documentation Updates)
121+
122+
#### 1. Update Service Registry Documentation
123+
**File**: `docs/architecture.md:97-114`
124+
```typescript
125+
// Current documentation
126+
export interface ServiceRegistry {
127+
cli: StepzenCliService;
128+
logger: Logger;
129+
projectResolver: ProjectResolver;
130+
schemaIndex: SchemaIndexService;
131+
}
132+
133+
// Should be updated to
134+
export interface ServiceRegistry {
135+
cli: StepzenCliService;
136+
logger: Logger;
137+
projectResolver: ProjectResolver;
138+
schemaIndex: SchemaIndexService;
139+
request: RequestService; // 🆕 Add
140+
import: ImportService; // 🆕 Add
141+
}
142+
```
143+
144+
#### 2. Document Schema Processing Organization
145+
**File**: `docs/architecture.md:42-46`
146+
Update to reflect actual file organization:
147+
```
148+
Schema Processing Layer (src/services/schema/)
149+
├── indexer.ts # Build searchable indexes
150+
├── linker.ts # SDL traversal & linking
151+
└── parser.ts # AST processing utilities
152+
```
153+
154+
#### 3. Add Command Categorization
155+
**File**: `docs/architecture.md:66`
156+
Document all 16 commands with categorization:
157+
```
158+
Commands (16 total):
159+
├── Core Operations: deploy, executeStepZenRequest, runRequest
160+
├── Navigation: goToDefinition, openExplorer, openSchemaVisualizer
161+
├── Project Management: initializeProject, generateOperations
162+
├── Import Commands: importCurl, importDatabase, importGraphql, importOpenapi
163+
└── Schema Enhancement: addDirective, addMaterializer, addTool, addValue
164+
```
165+
166+
### 🟡 Medium Priority (Implementation)
167+
168+
#### 4. Add Missing Test Utility
169+
Either implement the documented utility or remove from documentation:
170+
```typescript
171+
// Option 1: Implement utility
172+
export function createMockServiceRegistry(): ServiceRegistry {
173+
return {
174+
cli: createMock<StepzenCliService>(),
175+
logger: createMock<Logger>(),
176+
projectResolver: createMock<ProjectResolver>(),
177+
schemaIndex: createMock<SchemaIndexService>(),
178+
request: createMock<RequestService>(),
179+
import: createMock<ImportService>(),
180+
};
181+
}
182+
183+
// Option 2: Remove from documentation
184+
```
185+
186+
#### 5. Service Documentation Enhancement
187+
Add service descriptions to architecture documentation:
188+
- `RequestService`: GraphQL request execution and result handling
189+
- `ImportService`: Import command coordination and validation
190+
191+
### 🟢 Low Priority (Future Considerations)
192+
193+
#### 6. Service Composition Patterns
194+
Consider grouping related services for complex operations:
195+
```typescript
196+
// Future consideration - not needed currently
197+
interface ImportServiceGroup {
198+
import: ImportService;
199+
curl: CurlImportService;
200+
database: DatabaseImportService;
201+
graphql: GraphqlImportService;
202+
openapi: OpenapiImportService;
203+
}
204+
```
205+
206+
#### 7. Performance Monitoring
207+
Add hooks for future telemetry integration:
208+
```typescript
209+
// Future service addition
210+
interface ServiceRegistry {
211+
// ... existing services
212+
telemetry?: TelemetryService;
213+
performance?: PerformanceService;
214+
}
215+
```
216+
217+
## Code Quality Assessment
218+
219+
### ✅ Excellent Areas
220+
221+
1. **TypeScript Usage**: Strict typing, proper interfaces, clear types
222+
2. **Error Propagation**: Consistent error handling patterns
223+
3. **Logging**: Structured logging with appropriate levels
224+
4. **Testing**: Comprehensive coverage with proper mocking
225+
5. **Code Organization**: Clear separation of concerns
226+
6. **Security**: Proper workspace trust checks, safe command registration
227+
228+
### 🔧 Minor Improvements
229+
230+
1. **JSDoc Coverage**: Some public APIs could benefit from documentation
231+
2. **Configuration Management**: Consider centralized configuration service
232+
3. **Async Patterns**: Consistent promise handling (already quite good)
233+
234+
## Future Architecture Considerations
235+
236+
### 1. Planned Enhancements Support
237+
The current architecture provides excellent foundation for:
238+
- **Telemetry Integration**: Service registry easily extensible
239+
- **Language Server Protocol**: Schema processing layer ready
240+
- **Enhanced WebViews**: Panel architecture supports extensions
241+
- **Performance Monitoring**: Logging infrastructure ready
242+
243+
### 2. Migration Readiness
244+
- **Backward Compatibility**: Well-established patterns
245+
- **Incremental Changes**: Service-based architecture supports gradual updates
246+
- **Testing Infrastructure**: Comprehensive test coverage protects against regressions
247+
248+
## Conclusion
249+
250+
The VSCode StepZen extension demonstrates **exceptional architectural implementation** that follows best practices and provides a solid foundation for future enhancements. The implementation quality exceeds the documented architecture in several areas.
251+
252+
### Key Achievements
253+
- ✅ **Robust Service Registry**: Full dependency injection with testing support
254+
- ✅ **Comprehensive Commands**: 16 well-structured command implementations
255+
- ✅ **Excellent Error Handling**: Hierarchical, user-friendly, developer-friendly
256+
- ✅ **Strong Testing**: Unit, integration, and service mocking patterns
257+
- ✅ **Clear Code Organization**: Logical separation of concerns
258+
259+
### Immediate Actions Required
260+
1. **Update architecture documentation** to reflect actual implementation
261+
2. **Add missing test utility** or remove from documentation
262+
3. **Document all implemented commands** with categorization
263+
264+
### Long-term Strengths
265+
The architecture is well-positioned for future enhancements including telemetry, LSP integration, and advanced schema processing features. The service registry pattern and comprehensive error handling provide excellent foundation for extension growth.
266+
267+
**Recommendation**: Focus on documentation updates rather than implementation changes. The code architecture is exemplary and should serve as a model for similar VSCode extensions.

‎src/commands/generateOperations.ts‎

Lines changed: 1 addition & 3 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -134,7 +134,7 @@ export async function generateOperations() {
134134

135135
// Update SDL directive in index.graphql
136136
if (generatedFiles.length > 0) {
137-
updateSdlDirective(indexPath, generatedFiles); // TODO: cleanup when safe, projectRoot);
137+
updateSdlDirective(indexPath, generatedFiles);
138138
vscode.window.showInformationMessage(
139139
`Generated ${generatedFiles.length} operation files in the operations directory.`,
140140
);
@@ -286,8 +286,6 @@ function updateSdlDirective(
286286
// Also check for SDL directive without executables
287287
const sdlRegex = /@sdl\(([^)]*)\)/gs;
288288
let sdlWithoutExecutablesMatch = null;
289-
// TODO: remove
290-
// let originalLineEnding = content.includes("\r\n") ? "\r\n" : "\n";
291289

292290
// Find the schema directive that doesn't include executables
293291
let isSchemaDirective = false;

‎src/commands/importCurl.ts‎

Lines changed: 0 additions & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -39,8 +39,6 @@ export async function importCurl(): Promise<void> {
3939
`Schema imported successfully to ${result.targetDir}/${result.schemaName}`
4040
);
4141

42-
// TODO: Offer Phase 2 functional enhancements
43-
// await offerFunctionalEnhancements(result);
4442
} else {
4543
vscode.window.showErrorMessage(`Import failed: ${result.error}`);
4644
}

‎src/commands/importDatabase.ts‎

Lines changed: 0 additions & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -39,8 +39,6 @@ export async function importDatabase(): Promise<void> {
3939
`Database schema imported successfully to ${result.targetDir}/${result.schemaName}`
4040
);
4141

42-
// TODO: Offer Phase 2 functional enhancements
43-
// await offerFunctionalEnhancements(result);
4442
} else {
4543
vscode.window.showErrorMessage(`Import failed: ${result.error}`);
4644
}

‎src/commands/importGraphql.ts‎

Lines changed: 0 additions & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -39,8 +39,6 @@ export async function importGraphql(): Promise<void> {
3939
`GraphQL schema imported successfully to ${result.targetDir}/${result.schemaName}`
4040
);
4141

42-
// TODO: Offer Phase 2 functional enhancements
43-
// await offerFunctionalEnhancements(result);
4442
} else {
4543
vscode.window.showErrorMessage(`Import failed: ${result.error}`);
4644
}

‎src/commands/importOpenapi.ts‎

Lines changed: 0 additions & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -39,8 +39,6 @@ export async function importOpenapi(): Promise<void> {
3939
`OpenAPI schema imported successfully to ${result.targetDir}/${result.schemaName}`
4040
);
4141

42-
// TODO: Offer Phase 2 functional enhancements
43-
// await offerFunctionalEnhancements(result);
4442
} else {
4543
vscode.window.showErrorMessage(`Import failed: ${result.error}`);
4644
}

‎src/services/cli.ts‎

Lines changed: 0 additions & 58 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -245,64 +245,6 @@ export class StepzenCliService {
245245
}
246246
}
247247

248-
// TODO: CLEANUP
249-
// /**
250-
// * Spawn a StepZen CLI process with inherited stdio
251-
// *
252-
// * @param command The StepZen command to execute
253-
// * @param args Command arguments
254-
// * @param options Spawn options
255-
// * @returns Promise that resolves when the process completes
256-
// * @throws CliError if the process fails
257-
// */
258-
// private async spawnProcess(
259-
// command: string,
260-
// args: string[] = [],
261-
// options: cp.SpawnOptions = {}
262-
// ): Promise<void> {
263-
// return new Promise<void>((resolve, reject) => {
264-
// const fullArgs = [command, ...args];
265-
// const proc = cp.spawn('stepzen', fullArgs, {
266-
// shell: true,
267-
// ...options
268-
// });
269-
270-
// let stderr = '';
271-
272-
// if (proc.stderr) {
273-
// proc.stderr.on('data', (data) => {
274-
// const chunk = data.toString();
275-
// stderr += chunk;
276-
// logger.debug(`StepZen CLI stderr: ${chunk.trim()}`);
277-
// });
278-
// }
279-
280-
// proc.on('error', (err) => {
281-
// reject(new CliError(
282-
// `Failed to spawn StepZen CLI: ${err.message}`,
283-
// 'SPAWN_FAILED',
284-
// err
285-
// ));
286-
// });
287-
288-
// proc.on('close', (code) => {
289-
// if (code !== 0) {
290-
// // Create a more descriptive error with exit code and stderr
291-
// const errorMsg = stderr.trim()
292-
// ? `StepZen ${command} exited with code ${code}: ${stderr.trim()}`
293-
// : `StepZen ${command} exited with code ${code}`;
294-
295-
// reject(new CliError(
296-
// errorMsg,
297-
// 'COMMAND_FAILED',
298-
// stderr ? new Error(stderr) : undefined
299-
// ));
300-
// } else {
301-
// resolve();
302-
// }
303-
// });
304-
// });
305-
// }
306248

307249
/**
308250
* Spawn a StepZen CLI process and capture output

‎src/services/importService.ts‎

Lines changed: 1 addition & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -93,7 +93,7 @@ export class ImportService {
9393
success: true,
9494
targetDir: config.dir || './stepzen',
9595
schemaName: config.name,
96-
files: [] // TODO: Parse CLI output to get generated files
96+
files: [] // Note: CLI output parsing not implemented yet
9797
};
9898
} catch (cliError: any) {
9999
this.logger.error(`Import failed: ${cliError.message}`);

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)