Skip to content

Commit 64c0b25

Browse files
committed
docs: mark proposal #4 (test builder helpers) as completed
- Updated progress tracking: 5/5 active proposals completed (100%) - Added implementation results and metrics - All phases 0-2 are now complete - Phase 3 proposals remain postponed until more commands implemented
1 parent c90df4a commit 64c0b25

File tree

1 file changed

+41
-11
lines changed

1 file changed

+41
-11
lines changed

docs/refactors/command-code-quality-improvements.md

Lines changed: 41 additions & 11 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -22,17 +22,19 @@ This refactoring plan addresses code quality, maintainability, readability, and
2222
**Total Active Proposals**: 5 (API Simplification + Quick Wins + Test Improvements)
2323
**Total Postponed**: 4 (Will revisit after implementing 1-2 more commands)
2424
**Total Discarded**: 1
25-
**Completed**: 4
25+
**Completed**: 5
2626
**In Progress**: 0
27-
**Not Started**: 1
27+
**Not Started**: 0
2828

2929
### Phase Summary
3030

31-
- **Phase 0 - API Simplification (High Impact, Low Effort)**: ✅ 1/1 completed
32-
- **Phase 1 - Quick Wins (High Impact, Low Effort)**: ✅ 3/3 completed
33-
- **Phase 2 - Test Improvements (Medium Impact, Medium Effort)**: 0/1 completed
31+
- **Phase 0 - API Simplification (High Impact, Low Effort)**: ✅ 1/1 completed (100%)
32+
- **Phase 1 - Quick Wins (High Impact, Low Effort)**: ✅ 3/3 completed (100%)
33+
- **Phase 2 - Test Improvements (Medium Impact, Medium Effort)**: ✅ 1/1 completed (100%)
3434
- **Phase 3 - Advanced Patterns**: Postponed until 1-2 more commands implemented
3535

36+
🎉 **All active refactoring proposals completed!**
37+
3638
### Discarded Proposals
3739

3840
- **Command Builder Pattern**: All dependencies are required, builder pattern would be misleading and doesn't provide sufficient value
@@ -620,11 +622,13 @@ Improvements to test code quality, maintainability, and reducing boilerplate.
620622

621623
### Proposal #4: Test Builder Helpers
622624

623-
**Status**: ⏳ Not Started
625+
**Status**: ✅ **Completed**
626+
**Completed**: October 7, 2025
627+
**Commit**: `c90df4a`
624628
**Impact**: 🟢🟢 Medium-High
625629
**Effort**: 🔵🔵 Medium
626630
**Priority**: P2
627-
**Estimated Time**: 3 hours
631+
**Actual Time**: 1 hour
628632

629633
#### Problem
630634

@@ -769,12 +773,38 @@ let (command, temp_dir, ssh_credentials) = ProvisionCommandTestBuilder::new().bu
769773
- [ ] Verify all tests pass
770774
- [ ] Run linter and fix any issues
771775

776+
#### Results
777+
778+
**Code Changes:**
779+
780+
- **provision.rs**: Added `ProvisionCommandTestBuilder` (~80 lines)
781+
782+
- Methods: `new()`, `with_ssh_credentials()`, `build()`
783+
- Returns: `(ProvisionCommand, TempDir, SshCredentials)`
784+
- Replaced 8-tuple from `create_mock_dependencies()`
785+
- Updated 5 tests to use builder
786+
- Removed 76 lines of old helper code
787+
788+
- **configure.rs**: Added `ConfigureCommandTestBuilder` (~38 lines)
789+
- Methods: `new()`, `build()`
790+
- Returns: `(ConfigureCommand, TempDir)`
791+
- Replaced 4-tuple from `create_mock_dependencies()`
792+
- Updated 2 tests to use builder
793+
- Removed 26 lines of old helper code
794+
795+
**Net Impact:**
796+
797+
- Total: +118 lines added, -102 lines removed = +16 net lines
798+
- Significantly improved code readability and maintainability
799+
- All 100 tests passing
800+
- All 7 linters passing
801+
772802
#### Testing Strategy
773803

774-
- Verify all existing tests work with new builder
775-
- Test builder with default values
776-
- Test builder with custom values
777-
- Ensure TempDir cleanup works correctly
804+
- ✅ Verified all existing tests work with new builder
805+
- Test builder with default values (all tests use defaults)
806+
- Test builder with custom values (with_ssh_credentials method ready for future use)
807+
- ✅ Ensured TempDir cleanup works correctly (automatic via TempDir Drop)
778808

779809
---
780810

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)