review-log.md

Review Log

Status: scaffolded locally after Phase 1 patch
Purpose: human review history and pending review queue

Review Entries

Date	Item	Decision	Review requirement	Notes
2026-05-07	Initial public proof-stack scaffold	scaffolded	Human review required	Earlier scaffold prepared claim routing, status control, and boundary review before broader public proof use.
2026-05-13	Phase 1 profile/proof-stack execution plan	planned	Human review required	Plan authorized only the two control repositories: Franzabner and franzabner-proof-stack. No umbrella repo creation, supporting repo patch, push, publication, GitHub metadata change, or Hugging Face metadata change.
2026-05-13	Phase 1 local proof-stack patch	scaffolded	Human review required before push or public use	Rebuilt this repo around the approved 17-repo architecture, status vocabulary, claim register, artifact status, boundary register, review log, and proof-entry template.
2026-05-13	Phase 2 modular/CAD public scaffold repos	scaffolded	Human review required before profile routing or proof promotion	modular-infrastructure-studies and cad-mechanical-design-lab are public scaffold repos with validation scripts and first synthetic artifacts. They are not released, deployed, certified, product-ready, or proof-complete.
2026-05-14	Phase 3 electrical/embedded public scaffold repos	scaffolded	Human review required before proof promotion	electrical-controls-architecture and embedded-hardware-lab are public scaffold repos with validation scripts and first synthetic artifacts. They are not released, deployed, certified, manufacturing-ready, product-ready, or proof-complete.
2026-05-14	Phase 4 simulation/data public scaffold repos	scaffolded	Human review required before proof promotion	engineering-simulation-lab and data-model-infrastructure are public scaffold repos with validation scripts and first synthetic artifacts. They are not released, deployed, certified, benchmark-backed, physically validated, model-released, dataset-released, Space-released, fine-tuned-model-available, product-ready, or proof-complete.
2026-05-14	Phase 5 energy/civic production public scaffold repos	scaffolded	Human review required before proof promotion	infrastructure-energy-studies and civic-infrastructure-production-systems are public scaffold repos with validation scripts and first synthetic artifacts. They are not released, deployed, certified-safe, proven-output, operational Foundation program evidence, school-deployed, production-recycling-line evidence, live-civic-node evidence, manufacturing-ready, product-ready, or proof-complete.
2026-05-14	Phase 6 standards/security/deliverables public scaffold repos	scaffolded	Human review required before proof promotion	engineering-standards-and-validation, engineering-security-boundary, and engineering-deliverables-template are public scaffold repos with validation scripts and first synthetic artifacts. They are not released, certified, code-compliance approved, stamped, legally approved, customer-deliverable evidence, active-service evidence, model-released, dataset-released, Space-released, production-ready, or proof-complete.
2026-05-15	Phase 7 app/immersive/automation/agent public scaffold repos	scaffolded	Human review required before proof promotion	application-development-systems, immersive-access-systems, automated-engineering-systems, and agentic-engineering-workforce are public scaffold repos with validation scripts and first synthetic artifacts. They are not live apps, deployed portals, production automation, active agent workforce evidence, autonomous production-agent evidence, active-customer evidence, released software, active-service evidence, production-ready, or proof-complete.

Required Future Reviews

Review	Required before
Profile language review	Pushing or publicly relying on the patched Franzabner profile files or Phase 2/3/4/5/6/7 scaffold links.
Proof matrix review	Pushing or publicly relying on this proof stack as the control layer for Phase 2/3/4/5/6/7 scaffold routes.
Status vocabulary review	Any status change beyond planned or scaffolded.
Boundary review	Any supporting repo promotion, generated output, screenshot, CAD, KiCad, firmware, model/data artifact, Foundation-adjacent material, or client-related material.
Evidence review	Any published or released claim, artifact release, model/dataset/Space claim, benchmark, eval result, product claim, deployment claim, service claim, or certification claim.
Metadata review	Any GitHub profile bio, pin, repo description, topic, homepage, visibility, archive, or Hugging Face metadata change.
Umbrella repo creation review	Creating any additional umbrella or supporting repository.
Supporting repo patch review	Editing any existing narrow supporting repository.

Open Decisions

Decision	Current state
Are Franzabner and franzabner-proof-stack safe to push as scaffolded Phase 1 control repos?	Pending human review.
Are modular-infrastructure-studies and cad-mechanical-design-lab safe to route from Franzabner as scaffolded public proof surfaces?	Pending human review of this routing patch.
Are electrical-controls-architecture and embedded-hardware-lab safe to route from Franzabner as scaffolded public proof surfaces?	Pending human review of this routing patch.
Are engineering-simulation-lab and data-model-infrastructure safe to route from Franzabner as scaffolded public proof surfaces?	Pending human review of this routing patch.
Are infrastructure-energy-studies and civic-infrastructure-production-systems safe to route from Franzabner as scaffolded public proof surfaces?	Pending human review of this routing patch.
Are engineering-standards-and-validation, engineering-security-boundary, and engineering-deliverables-template safe to route from Franzabner as scaffolded public proof surfaces?	Pending human review of this routing patch.
Are application-development-systems, immersive-access-systems, automated-engineering-systems, and agentic-engineering-workforce safe to route from Franzabner as scaffolded public proof surfaces?	Pending human review of this routing patch.
Should any supporting narrow repo be rewritten, merged, replaced, archived, transferred, or made private/not-public?	Pending separate repo-by-repo review.
Should any GitHub or Hugging Face metadata change?	Not authorized by Phase 1.