Feedback from users

[LeonardoGentile]

Hello mates!
This little project of mine started to solve a personal problem but it turns out other people are using it ;)

I'd like to have a little feedback if you have a couple of minutes:

1. How/where are you using this? (big/small apps, personal projects?)
2. Are you using the getComponent or RouteView utilities or using a plain ol' switch?
3. Is the README too complex to follow? Do you think it could be simplified?

Thanks!

[micros123]

Hi Leonardo,
I'm trying to switch a big project over from React-Router v4 to Router5. So far I'm using switch, but may try the utils once I get my head wrapped around Router5 more.
My most important request would be: Please create a basic example project. A ToDo App or something even simpler, and apply all best practices. Maybe two alternative versions using different design patterns. That would make understanding Router5 with your MobX/React integration so much easier to follow than just docs.

[LeonardoGentile]

@micros123 thanks for your feedback

Why are moving away from React-Router v4? Wondering if others have the same reasons :]

Have you checked https://github.com/LeonardoGentile/react-mobx-router5-example? Surely it's not a complex and in-depth example, I've been planning something more serious for a while, I just need some time

[micros123]

Two main reasons:

1. Making API calls based on route changes requires a lot of custom code.
2. The bad handling of transitions. I tried AnimatedSwitch. But I still sometimes see two states at the same time, then one disappears, making the page very jumpy.

I'll have a look at your example.