Skip to content

AgentHost: ask_user question is presented as plan #316544

@roblourens

Description

@roblourens
Image
{"type":"assistant.message","data":{"messageId":"f07e6ee1-4ab3-488e-90ce-fcafb593920c","content":"","toolRequests":[{"toolCallId":"call_GJ9rlaiQCuixYoOEh0CRaCBs","name":"ask_user","arguments":{"question":"# dap-cli\n\n**Progress:** [████████████████████] 91/88 plans (100%)\n**Profile:** quality\n**Discuss mode:** discuss\n\n## Recent Work\n- **Phase 19 / Plan 02:** `dap-cli help` now renders seven locked command categories and keeps `serve-controller` hidden.\n- **Phase 19 / Plan 01:** `dap-cli help` no longer emits the bogus usage-error envelope and drill-down help works for nested commands.\n- **Phase 17 / Plan 01:** the 20-scenario Code OSS attach matrix was created.\n\n## Current Position\nThe live project docs say **v0.1.0 shipped** and **v0.2.0 is not scoped yet**, but the artifact scan still detects **Phase 17** as incomplete: **2 plans, 1 summary**. Phase 19 is complete: **2 plans, 2 summaries**.\n\n## Blockers/Concerns\n- **Phase 17 UAT is failed**, with five failed gaps including Hand-Driven Smoke B not matching the documented timeout expectation.\n- **Verification debt:** 1 unresolved skipped UAT item remains in Phase 05 (`05-UAT-GAP-CLOSURE.md`).\n- **Active debug sessions:** 1 debug note exists under `.planning/debug/`.\n- **Uncommitted source/doc changes:** `README.md` and `dap-cli/skills/dap-cli/SKILL.md` are modified in the working tree.\n\n## ▶ Next Up — dap-cli\n\n**Recommended route:** `/gsd-execute-phase 17` — complete the missing Phase 17 execution record/summary before advancing.\n\n**Important follow-up:** Phase 17’s UAT recommendation says to start gap closure for GAP-17-S14, GAP-17-S16, GAP-17-S19, then resolve or intentionally revise Hand-Driven Smoke B before marking UAT complete.\n\nWhat should I do next?","choices":["/gsd-execute-phase 17 (recommended)","/gsd-plan-phase 17 --gaps","/gsd-new-milestone","Done for now"],"allow_freeform":true},"type":"function","toolTitle":"Asking user","intentionSummary":"# dap-cli\n\n**Progress:** [████████████████████] 91/88 pla..."}],"interactionId":"6e64f011-0c3e-4e63-812e-2778d9e2e596","reasoningOpaque":"GHygsYF+/A8nKT9Pp89zXTMUMFH8/sGbYS+JSPdFz6n0RGkXvjACeVWc6P8nvV+6EzaApU2n/z/O8tVJmgL619VxuPDePPUFP72AsCThQXMAkSGQhBv3EYj/aKYyqgvhGDoEFS4QatW1jHu268vi11ucuD3XW+gN+aLs8+G+pPb+STrrBmbedO9DiGSDn/Uf/u8RTngNziqYunyBkIbaGtzQu3L9aa+R0lkQMNq1gvIvQOhmnKSjfTfQShcQGVrhDSD3+bQJoLadNuwrZyx73AhkbdCBtA5CQXXVjqZficvj16inGyl8VlhNb1Hi8u0EVd8lA0ifFsl3VTLOBWRWkUGijWciknDD27BOugRP64eO1qghe/sXfF5n030oLhHTIj+Rh5LTkHs+XjqT22ccWQ==","encryptedContent":"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","outputTokens":919,"requestId":"DC59:3D8EFC:17CD7C9:1AA0BEE:6A067E8D"},"id":"5ef3fb59-8ca9-4d7d-b161-1495e05b825d","timestamp":"2026-05-15T02:02:04.876Z","parentId":"61457997-3af0-497e-992c-daca4b59d4ab"}
{"type":"tool.execution_start","data":{"toolCallId":"call_GJ9rlaiQCuixYoOEh0CRaCBs","toolName":"ask_user","arguments":{"question":"# dap-cli\n\n**Progress:** [████████████████████] 91/88 plans (100%)\n**Profile:** quality\n**Discuss mode:** discuss\n\n## Recent Work\n- **Phase 19 / Plan 02:** `dap-cli help` now renders seven locked command categories and keeps `serve-controller` hidden.\n- **Phase 19 / Plan 01:** `dap-cli help` no longer emits the bogus usage-error envelope and drill-down help works for nested commands.\n- **Phase 17 / Plan 01:** the 20-scenario Code OSS attach matrix was created.\n\n## Current Position\nThe live project docs say **v0.1.0 shipped** and **v0.2.0 is not scoped yet**, but the artifact scan still detects **Phase 17** as incomplete: **2 plans, 1 summary**. Phase 19 is complete: **2 plans, 2 summaries**.\n\n## Blockers/Concerns\n- **Phase 17 UAT is failed**, with five failed gaps including Hand-Driven Smoke B not matching the documented timeout expectation.\n- **Verification debt:** 1 unresolved skipped UAT item remains in Phase 05 (`05-UAT-GAP-CLOSURE.md`).\n- **Active debug sessions:** 1 debug note exists under `.planning/debug/`.\n- **Uncommitted source/doc changes:** `README.md` and `dap-cli/skills/dap-cli/SKILL.md` are modified in the working tree.\n\n## ▶ Next Up — dap-cli\n\n**Recommended route:** `/gsd-execute-phase 17` — complete the missing Phase 17 execution record/summary before advancing.\n\n**Important follow-up:** Phase 17’s UAT recommendation says to start gap closure for GAP-17-S14, GAP-17-S16, GAP-17-S19, then resolve or intentionally revise Hand-Driven Smoke B before marking UAT complete.\n\nWhat should I do next?","choices":["/gsd-execute-phase 17 (recommended)","/gsd-plan-phase 17 --gaps","/gsd-new-milestone","Done for now"],"allow_freeform":true}},"id":"85153a9b-ac9c-4ca5-bf06-034967e8327b","timestamp":"2026-05-15T02:02:04.877Z","parentId":"5ef3fb59-8ca9-4d7d-b161-1495e05b825d"}

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

agent-hostIssues for the agent-host implementation (not the protocol)bugIssue identified by VS Code Team member as probable bug

Type

No type

Projects

Status

No status

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions