Skip to content

Conversation

@solimander
Copy link
Collaborator

Summary

Fixes app name resolution to check remote profiles instead of only the legacy local registry (which only contained apps created before profile names were added). Adds 24-hour caching to speed up commands and prevent rate limiting.

Changes

  • AppResolver checks remote profiles first, falls back to local registry
  • 24-hour disk cache for profile names in GlobalConfig
  • Cache invalidated on app deploy and app profile set
  • Prevents parallel API requests from triggering rate limits

Impact

  • App name resolution now works for apps with remote profiles
  • Subsequent commands are instant after initial cache
  • No more "app not found" errors for apps with profiles

@claude
Copy link

claude bot commented Nov 21, 2025

Claude finished @solimander's task —— View job


PR Review Complete ✅

I've thoroughly analyzed this PR that centralizes app name resolution with AppResolver and profile caching. Here's my comprehensive review:

🌟 Overall Assessment: Excellent Implementation

This is a well-architected solution that addresses a real usability issue. The code quality is high, with good separation of concerns and proper error handling.

Strengths

Architecture & Design

  • Clean separation: New AppResolver centralizes all app name resolution logic
  • Proper caching: 24-hour TTL with smart cache invalidation on deploy/profile changes
  • Interface adoption: Added iface.AppNameResolver interface for loose coupling
  • Fallback strategy: Remote profiles first, then local registry (legacy support)

Performance Improvements

  • Batch processing: API calls use batching with parallel execution in getProfileNamesForApps
  • Single resolver instance: Commands reuse the same resolver to avoid duplicate API calls
  • Disk-based cache: Prevents repeated network calls within 24-hour window

Code Quality

  • Comprehensive error handling: Graceful degradation when API calls fail
  • Good documentation: Clear function comments explaining behavior
  • Case-insensitive matching: Improves user experience for name resolution
  • Clean refactoring: Removed old name.go and consolidated logic appropriately

⚠️ Areas for Improvement

Minor Issues

  1. Thread Safety (pkg/commands/utils/app_resolver.go:193):

    // Potential race condition if multiple goroutines call ensureCacheInitialized
    if r.cacheInitialized {
        return nil
    }

    Recommendation: Add a mutex or use sync.Once for initialization.

  2. Error Handling (pkg/commands/utils/app_resolver.go:196):

    _ = common.SaveProfileCache(r.environmentName, r.profileNames)

    Recommendation: Log cache save failures for debugging.

  3. Magic Numbers (pkg/commands/utils/app_resolver.go:121):

    for i := 2; i <= 100; i++ {

    Recommendation: Define MaxNameRetries = 100 as a constant.

  4. Cache Key Collision (pkg/common/global_config.go:203):
    The cache uses environment name as key, but if two environments have the same name from different sources, they could collide.

Performance Considerations

  1. API Request Batching: Current batch size appears to be MaxAppsPerRequest but this constant isn't visible in the files reviewed. Ensure it's appropriately sized.

  2. Goroutine Leak Prevention: The parallel API calls in getProfileNamesForApps look correct, but consider adding context cancellation for long-running operations.

🔒 Security Assessment

  • No security vulnerabilities identified
  • Proper input validation for app IDs and names
  • No sensitive data exposure in caching
  • Safe string operations with proper trimming and validation

🧪 Test Coverage Concern

Missing test coverage for the new AppResolver functionality. Given the complexity and importance of this component, I recommend adding:

// Suggested test cases:
- TestAppResolver_ResolveAppID_ValidHexAddress
- TestAppResolver_ResolveAppID_ProfileNameMatch  
- TestAppResolver_ResolveAppID_LocalRegistryFallback
- TestAppResolver_GetAppName_CacheHit
- TestAppResolver_FindAvailableName_Incremental
- TestAppResolver_CacheInitialization_ThreadSafety

📋 Code Quality Checklist

Todo List

  • Read CLAUDE.md for repo guidelines
  • Analyze the new AppResolver implementation
  • Review caching mechanism in GlobalConfig
  • Check removed name.go functionality
  • Review modified command files for integration
  • Assess code quality and best practices
  • Check for potential bugs or issues
  • Evaluate performance considerations
  • Review security concerns
  • Assess test coverage

🎯 Recommendations

  1. Add thread safety to AppResolver initialization
  2. Add comprehensive tests for the new resolver functionality
  3. Consider adding metrics to monitor cache hit rates
  4. Document the 24-hour TTL decision - consider making it configurable

🚀 Impact Assessment

This PR successfully addresses the original problem:

  • ✅ App name resolution now works for apps with remote profiles
  • ✅ Commands are fast after initial cache load
  • ✅ No more "app not found" errors for profile-enabled apps
  • ✅ Maintains backward compatibility with legacy local registry

Recommendation: APPROVE - This is a solid implementation that significantly improves user experience while maintaining good code quality and performance.


@solimander solimander merged commit 71d9994 into main Nov 21, 2025
12 checks passed
@solimander solimander deleted the soli/fix-name-fetching branch November 21, 2025 23:11
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants