Conversation
|
Currently, the ridership data is not one-to-one with the existing network topology:
Screenshot below shows the MBTA Rapid Transit dataset with points colored by "total_ridership" (with colormap "greens" and null color red) and lines colored by feature props. |
|
@annehaley I've resolved most of the discrepancies. As you mentioned, many come down to small name variations. Back of the Hill ... Back Of The Hill Check your matching algorithm for these stations which we have all the data for: Chestnut Hill (not Chestnut Hill Avenue), Quincy Center (not Quincy Adams), BU East (not BU Central). There are two more I see on your screenshot where we have all the data so I'm not sure what the issue is: Sutherland Road, Haymarket. Aside from the above, it looks like all the missing stations come from the Red Line streetcar portion (riders actually change vehicles there) and the Silver Line (which is physically buses even though advertised as subway-equivalent). Red Line streetcar: Cedar Grove, Butler, Milton, Central Avenue, Valley Road, Capen Street, Mattapan I'll look for Red Line streetcar data and Silver Line data - hopefully there's a dataset we can integrate with what we've already done. |
|
@augustposch Thanks for identifying the name discrepancies. I should have anticipated that a case-insensitive match would be appropriate for this. I also removed apostrophes from the station names and applied some custom replacements before looking for matches. Besides the known missing stations along the silver line and red line streetcar, the remaining discrepancies were actually due to a bug with the way we generate features for a network. Some node features were getting created more than once, so the duplicates were not getting the ridership data saved. I fixed this bug in faed8d5. Here's what the ridership visualization looks like now: If this looks good to you, we can merge this version and work on the other missing data later. |
augustposch
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
New screenshot looks good. Glad you identified all the issues and fixed these! I'll look into the silver line and red line streetcar data this week.
Deploying geoinsight with
|
| Latest commit: |
45991ab
|
| Status: | ✅ Deploy successful! |
| Preview URL: | https://8c76ab6f.geoinsight.pages.dev |
| Branch Preview URL: | https://mbta-ridership.geoinsight.pages.dev |


This PR leverages the
ingest_mbtacustom dataset conversion to add ridership data to the MBTA Rapid Transit dataset. Ridership data was provided by @augustposch. This PR also makes a slight change to the Legend panel so that the ridership range will appear on either side of the color bar.Note: To apply these changes, the MBTA Rapid Transit dataset must be overwritten. Re-run the ingest task with "action": "replace" added to the JSON specification for that dataset.