Skip to content

Conversation

@dicksontsai
Copy link
Collaborator

Compare against the Typescript SDK

export type McpStdioServerConfig = {
  type?: 'stdio' // Optional for backwards compatibility
  command: string
  args?: string[]
  env?: Record<string, string>
}

export type McpSSEServerConfig = {
  type: 'sse'
  url: string
  headers?: Record<string, string>
}

export type McpHttpServerConfig = {
  type: 'http'
  url: string
  headers?: Record<string, string>
}

export type McpServerConfig = McpStdioServerConfig | McpSSEServerConfig | McpHttpServerConfig

@dicksontsai dicksontsai requested a review from ltawfik June 25, 2025 08:01
@claude
Copy link
Contributor

claude bot commented Jun 25, 2025

Claude finished @dicksontsai's task —— View job


Code Review Complete ✅

Todo List:

  • Read and analyze the modified src/claude_code_sdk/types.py file
  • Compare Python types against provided TypeScript reference types
  • Review code quality and best practices
  • Check for potential bugs or issues
  • Assess performance considerations
  • Evaluate security concerns
  • Review test coverage implications
  • Provide comprehensive feedback

Review Summary

The MCP types update successfully aligns the Python SDK with the TypeScript SDK reference. The implementation is well-structured and follows Python typing best practices.

Code Quality & Best Practices

Excellent alignment with TypeScript reference:

  • Correctly uses TypedDict classes for structured config objects
  • Proper use of NotRequired for optional fields (equivalent to TypeScript's ?)
  • Literal types used appropriately for discriminated union
  • Modern Python union syntax (|) used consistently
  • Clear docstrings for each config type

Strong typing implementation:

# Perfect mapping from TypeScript optional fields
type: NotRequired[Literal["stdio"]]  # TypeScript: type?: 'stdio'
args: NotRequired[list[str]]         # TypeScript: args?: string[]

Potential Issues Analysis

No bugs identified. The implementation correctly mirrors the TypeScript types:

  • Discriminated union: Properly implemented with type field as discriminator
  • Optional fields: All optional fields from TypeScript correctly marked with NotRequired
  • Type consistency: dict[str, str] correctly maps to Record<string, string>

Performance Considerations

Minimal performance impact:

  • TypedDict has negligible runtime overhead compared to regular dicts
  • Union types resolved at type-check time, no runtime cost
  • Structure is lightweight and appropriate for configuration objects

Security Considerations

No security concerns:

  • No dynamic code execution or eval usage
  • Type definitions are purely declarative
  • Configuration fields are properly typed to prevent injection issues

🔍 Test Coverage Implications

Recommendation: Consider adding tests to verify:

# Example test cases to consider
def test_mcp_stdio_config():
    config: McpStdioServerConfig = {"command": "python", "args": ["-m", "server"]}
    assert config["command"] == "python"

def test_mcp_server_config_union():
    # Test that union type accepts all variants
    stdio_config: McpServerConfig = {"command": "python"}
    sse_config: McpServerConfig = {"type": "sse", "url": "https://example.com"}
    # etc.

Overall Assessment

LGTM! This PR successfully achieves its goal of aligning Python MCP types with the TypeScript SDK. The implementation is:

  • Accurate: Perfect 1:1 mapping with TypeScript reference
  • Idiomatic: Uses appropriate Python typing constructs
  • Maintainable: Clear structure and documentation
  • Future-proof: Uses modern Python typing features

Recommendation: ✅ Approve and merge


@dicksontsai dicksontsai merged commit 52cc0db into main Jun 25, 2025
7 checks passed
@dicksontsai dicksontsai deleted the dickson/mcp branch June 25, 2025 15:06
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants