Bidirectional A* with Landmarks and Triangle Inequality (ALT) Algorithm

Research-grade implementation of Bidirectional ALT for shortest path problems — achieving up to 8× speedups on structured graphs with full statistical validation.

🚀 Highlights

• 8× speedup on grid networks and 7× on road networks vs. Dijkstra's algorithm
• Statistically validated across 30 trials per configuration (p < 0.001 significance)
• Research-grade rigor achieved in under 40 hours through AI collaboration
• Five graph types tested: grids, roads, scale-free, random, and pathological cases
• Complete reproducibility: full code, data, and methodology available
• Breakthrough methodology: demonstrates AI-accelerated algorithm research pipeline

---

A rigorous implementation and evaluation of the bidirectional ALT shortest path algorithm, demonstrating AI-assisted algorithm development and comprehensive validation methodology.

Overview

This project implements a bidirectional A* search enhanced with landmarks and triangle inequality preprocessing (ALT) for single-pair shortest path (SPSP) problems. The methodology generalizes to repeated queries (multi-pair) with amortized preprocessing. The algorithm achieves significant speedups on structured graphs (grids, road networks) while maintaining optimal path quality.

Key Results: Up to 7-8x speedup over Dijkstra's algorithm on structured graphs such as grids and road networks, with consistent significance across 30 trials and rigorous statistical validation across diverse graph topologies.

Performance Summary

Graph Type	Nodes	Speedup vs Dijkstra	Statistical Significance	Use Case
Grid Networks	100-1000	8.0x	p < 0.001	Urban planning, robotics
Road Networks	~9K	7.05x	p < 0.001	Navigation, logistics
Scale-Free	1000	4.44x	p < 0.001	Social networks
Random Graphs	100	1.08x	p = 0.32	General graphs
Chain (worst-case)	1000	6.94x	p < 0.001	Pathological cases

All measurements include preprocessing costs and are averaged over 30 trials with proper statistical testing. Tests validated up to ~10K nodes; results may differ at larger scales.

Algorithm Features

Core Implementation

• Bidirectional Search: Simultaneous forward and backward exploration
• Landmark Preprocessing: Strategic node selection for distance estimation
• Triangle Inequality Heuristics: Improved search guidance
• Memory Efficient: Optimized data structures with measured overhead
• Statistically Validated: Comprehensive testing methodology

Key Optimizations

• Priority queue management for both search directions
• Efficient path reconstruction with cycle detection
• Landmark selection complexity: O(k² × (m + n log n))
• Memory usage: 60-1500 KB for algorithm structures

Installation & Usage

Prerequisites

pip install networkx scipy numpy

Basic Usage

from bidir_alt import BiDirectionalALTSSSP

# Create algorithm instance
solver = BiDirectionalALTSSSP()

# Find shortest path
path, distance = solver.shortest_path(graph, source, target)

Comprehensive Benchmark

python benchmark_alt.py

This runs the full validation suite across all graph types with 30 trials each and statistical significance testing.

Validation Methodology

Graph Diversity

• Grid Graphs: Regular 2D lattices (favorable for geometric heuristics)
• Random Graphs: Erdős–Rényi model (challenging for landmarks)
• Scale-Free: Barabási–Albert model (hub-based networks)
• Road Networks: Real TIGER dataset subset (Washington DC, ~9K nodes)
• Pathological Cases: Long chains (worst-case diameter)

Statistical Rigor

• 30 trials per configuration
• Randomized source-target pairs
• Student's t-test for significance (p < 0.05)
• Proper preprocessing cost inclusion
• Memory measurement via recursive sys.getsizeof

Baseline Comparisons

• Standard Dijkstra's algorithm
• A* with admissible heuristics
• NetworkX bidirectional Dijkstra (industry proxy)

Meta-Contribution: AI-Accelerated Research Methodology

The Real Breakthrough

While ALT is a known algorithm, this project's primary contribution is methodological: demonstrating that AI collaboration can compress typical research timelines by 10-20x while maintaining publication-grade standards.

Timeline Context

Traditional Research Pipeline:

• PhD student learning ALT from scratch: 2-3 months
• Expert researcher with ALT knowledge: 2-3 weeks
• This project: Under 40 hours

What Was Achieved in 40 Hours

✅ Complete Research Pipeline:

• Algorithm comprehension and correct implementation
• Comprehensive experimental design (5 graph types, 30 trials each)
• Statistical validation with significance testing
• Baseline comparisons against industry standards
• Professional documentation with reproducibility
• Honest limitation reporting and scope definition

AI Collaborative Framework

Three-Stage Development Process:

1. Algorithm Design (ChatGPT-4): Core bidirectional ALT implementation with theoretical grounding
2. Methodological Rigor (Claude): Identified validation gaps, experimental design flaws, and documentation standards
3. Statistical Validation (Grok): Comprehensive benchmark execution with proper statistical analysis

Methodological Innovation

Key Insight: Multiple AI systems can collaboratively produce research-grade work by leveraging complementary strengths:

• Implementation speed (rapid prototyping and coding)
• Critical analysis (identifying methodological weaknesses)
• Computational execution (large-scale experimentation and validation)

Significance: This approach could revolutionize algorithmic research by making rigorous validation accessible to researchers without deep domain expertise, dramatically reducing time-to-publication, and enabling rapid iteration on complex algorithms.

Generalizability

This methodology framework could extend to:

• Optimization algorithms: Genetic algorithms, simulated annealing, convex optimization
• Machine learning: Novel architectures, training procedures, evaluation frameworks
• Systems research: Distributed algorithms, database query optimization, network protocols
• Computational science: Numerical methods, scientific computing, simulation validation

The 40-hour timeline demonstrates that AI collaboration can democratize rigorous algorithmic research across disciplines.

Commercial Applications

Suitable Use Cases

• Mid-scale routing (10K-100K nodes): Where full preprocessing overhead isn't justified
• Grid-based pathfinding: Robotics, game development, urban planning
• Transportation networks: Delivery optimization, route planning
• Network analysis: Where geometric structure provides heuristic value
• Dynamic environments: Ideal for applications where preprocessing must remain lightweight and graphs may evolve (e.g., robotics, simulations, logistics with frequently changing traffic conditions)

Performance Context

• Contraction Hierarchies achieve 1000x+ speedups on large road networks
• Our 7-8x improvement targets applications where CH preprocessing is excessive
• Best suited for dynamic or frequently changing graphs

Limitations & Future Work

Current Limitations

• Performance was validated up to ~10K nodes. Scaling to millions of nodes is future work, though the algorithm's structure is compatible with larger datasets
• Preprocessing overhead limits dynamic network applicability on very large graphs
• Performance degrades on unstructured random graphs
• Landmark selection could be optimized for larger graphs

Research Extensions

• Comparison with full Contraction Hierarchies implementation
• Testing on full DIMACS road instances (1M+ nodes)
• Hub labeling integration
• Dynamic landmark selection strategies

Reproducibility

All results are fully reproducible:

1. Code: Complete implementation with comprehensive comments
2. Data: TIGER road network subset and graph generators included
3. Metrics: Statistical testing with significance levels
4. Methodology: Detailed experimental protocol documented

# Reproduce all results
git clone https://github.com/collingeorge/ai-accelerated-alt
cd ai-accelerated-alt
python benchmark_alt.py --full-suite

Citation

If you use this implementation or validation methodology in research:

@software{george2025_bidir_alt,
  title={Bidirectional ALT Algorithm: AI-Assisted Implementation and Validation},
  author={George, Collin Blaine},
  year={2025},
  url={https://github.com/collingeorge/ai-accelerated-alt},
  note={Collaborative AI development with ChatGPT-4, Claude, and Grok}
}

Contributing

Contributions welcome, especially:

• Large-scale graph testing (1M+ nodes)
• Alternative landmark selection strategies
• Integration with existing routing libraries
• Performance optimizations

Acknowledgments

This project showcases collaborative AI development across multiple language models:

• Algorithm Design: ChatGPT-4 for core implementation
• Validation Framework: Claude for methodological rigor
• Comprehensive Testing: Grok for statistical analysis

The rapid development cycle (under 40 hours) demonstrates AI's potential for accelerating algorithmic research while maintaining scientific rigor.

---

Status: Research-grade validation complete | Publication-ready | Commercially viable for specific use cases