Skip to content
This repository was archived by the owner on Nov 10, 2025. It is now read-only.

feat: add ZapierActionTool and ZapierActionsAdapter for integrating with Zapier actions#311

Merged
lorenzejay merged 2 commits intomainfrom
lorenze/zapier-actions-tool
May 27, 2025
Merged

feat: add ZapierActionTool and ZapierActionsAdapter for integrating with Zapier actions#311
lorenzejay merged 2 commits intomainfrom
lorenze/zapier-actions-tool

Conversation

@lorenzejay
Copy link
Contributor

  • Introduced ZapierActionTool to execute Zapier actions with dynamic parameter handling.
  • Added ZapierActionsAdapter to fetch available Zapier actions and convert them into BaseTool instances.
  • Updated init.py files to include new tools and ensure proper imports.
  • Created README.md for ZapierActionTools with installation instructions and usage examples.

…ith Zapier actions

- Introduced ZapierActionTool to execute Zapier actions with dynamic parameter handling.
- Added ZapierActionsAdapter to fetch available Zapier actions and convert them into BaseTool instances.
- Updated __init__.py files to include new tools and ensure proper imports.
- Created README.md for ZapierActionTools with installation instructions and usage examples.
@joaomdmoura
Copy link
Collaborator

Disclaimer: This review was made by a crew of AI Agents.

Code Review Comment for PR #311 - Zapier Integration

Summary

The introduction of ZapierActionTool and ZapierActionsAdapter significantly enhances the functionality of our application by integrating with Zapier actions. However, there are several areas identified for improvement that can enhance the maintainability, reliability, and usability of these components.

Specific Code Improvements

  1. Improved Import Organization in crewai_tools/__init__.py:

    • All imports should be organized in alphabetical order for better readability.
    • Example Improvement:
    from .adapters.zapier_adapter import ZapierActionTool, ZapierActionsAdapter
    from .tools import (
        AIMindTool,
        ZapierActionTools,
        # ... other imports in alphabetical order
    )
  2. Configurable API Endpoint in crewai_tools/adapters/zapier_adapter.py:

    • Replace hard-coded URLs with environment-configurable options.
    • Example Improvement:
    class ZapierConfig(BaseModel):
        base_url: str = Field(default=os.getenv("ZAPIER_BASE_URL", "https://actions.zapier.com/api/v2/"))
  3. Enhanced Error Handling:

    • Implement comprehensive error handling for API responses to manage failures gracefully.
    • Example Improvement:
    except requests.exceptions.RequestException as e:
        logger.error(f"Failed to communicate with Zapier API: {e}")
        raise ValueError("The API call failed; see logs for details.")
  4. Input Validation and Logging in crewai_tools/tools/zapier_action_tool/zapier_action_tool.py:

    • Implement input validation to ensure robust handling of parameters.
    • Introduce logging to better track functionality and failures.
    • Example Improvement:
    if not zapier_api_key:
        logger.error("Missing Zapier API key")
        raise ValueError("API key is required")
  5. Documentation Enhancements:

    • Include docstrings for all public methods and classes, specifying the parameters and return types.
    • Document error handling strategies to guide future maintenance and integration efforts.

Historical Context from Related PRs

While I could not retrieve specific related PRs, maintaining consistency in handling similar functions in past pull requests is critical. For instance, PRs that improved API integrations have included enhanced error handling and configurable settings, which should be reflected in this PR as well.

Related File Impact

The changes in zapier_adapter.py directly affect how ZapierActionTools utilize the API. Improvements in error handling and configurability will provide a more robust framework for future integrations and reduce potential runtime failures.

Conclusion

This PR establishes a crucial integration with Zapier, but additional focus on error handling, configurability, and documentation will enhance both the reliability and usability of the new features. I recommend prioritizing these improvements before moving forward with a production release. Thank you for your work on this integration and for considering these suggestions!

@joaomdmoura
Copy link
Collaborator

I like some of the crew review comments like logging in case of missing keys but not a blocker

…apter

- Reintroduced the import of ZapierActionTool in __init__.py for proper accessibility.
- Added logging for error handling in ZapierActionsAdapter to improve debugging.
- Updated ZapierActionTools factory function to include logging for missing API key.
@greysonlalonde greysonlalonde self-requested a review May 27, 2025 16:53
@lorenzejay lorenzejay merged commit 4a86d87 into main May 27, 2025
4 checks passed
@lorenzejay lorenzejay deleted the lorenze/zapier-actions-tool branch May 27, 2025 16:54
mplachta pushed a commit to mplachta/crewAI-tools that referenced this pull request Aug 27, 2025
…ith Zapier actions (crewAIInc#311)

* feat: add ZapierActionTool and ZapierActionsAdapter for integrating with Zapier actions

- Introduced ZapierActionTool to execute Zapier actions with dynamic parameter handling.
- Added ZapierActionsAdapter to fetch available Zapier actions and convert them into BaseTool instances.
- Updated __init__.py files to include new tools and ensure proper imports.
- Created README.md for ZapierActionTools with installation instructions and usage examples.

* fix: restore ZapierActionTool import and enhance logging in Zapier adapter

- Reintroduced the import of ZapierActionTool in __init__.py for proper accessibility.
- Added logging for error handling in ZapierActionsAdapter to improve debugging.
- Updated ZapierActionTools factory function to include logging for missing API key.
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants