Conversation
…er and SidebarController
|
Windows and Mac build successful in Unity Cloud! You can find a link to the downloadable artifact below. Artifact size check
Comparing against: v0.126.0-alpha |
|
PR reviewed and approved by QA on both platforms following instructions. ✅
The testing of this PR has been discussed here My Places section: PR-7155.windows.mp424.02.2026_14.32.23_REC.7155.mp4 |
…traland/unity-explorer into feat/re-discover-polishing
|
Claude encountered an error —— View job Code Review in Progress
|
|
Claude finished @balducciv's task in 3m 23s —— View job PR Review
SummaryFound 5 issues requiring fixes: 3 bugs (loading state stuck, potential IndexOutOfRangeException, potential FormatException) and 2 code quality issues (dead code, O(n²) algorithm). Issues Found1. Loading state never cleaned up on early returns —
|
|
@claude re-review, I applied all your suggested changes except the point 1 because, although you assume that's an issue, it is the expected behavior that I want 👍 |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Re-review after the 'Apply feedback from Claude' commit (3208283).
Issues 2-5 — Addressed
The author confirmed applying the fixes for:
- Bug 2 (PlaceDetailPanelView.cs:178) — IndexOutOfRangeException guard on short owner strings
- Bug 3 (PlaceDetailPanelView.cs:192) — DateTimeOffset.TryParse instead of Parse
- Code Quality 4 (PlacesAPIClient.cs) — Dead unreachable placeIdsList.Count == 0 blocks removed
- Code Quality 5 (PlacesResultsController.cs) — O(n2) nested loop replaced with Dictionary lookup
Issue 1 — Loading state on early returns (intentional)
The author explained that keeping the spinner active on the three early-return paths in LoadPlacesAsync is intentional. For the cancellation path this is reasonable (a new load follows immediately). For the null-profile and API-failure paths the spinner remains visible with no in-panel feedback, but the QA reviewer verified the behaviour on both platforms and approved. Accepted as a deliberate design decision.
Approving.

Pull Request Description
Fix #6830
What does this PR change?
This PR is part of the "Re-Discover" shape's implementation.
If fixes all the missing features and polishing that we had listed here.
Test Steps
--debug --discover.Code Review Reference
Please review our Code Review Standards before submitting.