Skip to content

Conversation

@pftg
Copy link
Member

@pftg pftg commented Sep 30, 2025

Summary by CodeRabbit

  • New Features

    • Added a CSS migration performance monitor to track build time and CSS bundle sizes with quality gates.
  • Documentation

    • Introduced comprehensive CSS migration materials: critical findings, optimization recommendations, performance baseline, duplication analysis, component inventory, progress tracker, roadmap, Sprint 5 plan, and visual regression testing protocol.
    • Added MCP tooling adoption and integration reports.
    • Removed several legacy CSS strategy and report documents to reduce duplication.
  • Chores

    • Updated a dependency to source from GitHub for improved reliability.
    • Removed local settings configuration to simplify environment setup.
  • Style

    • Streamlined task start/completion messaging across assistants.

pftg added 30 commits September 29, 2025 11:12
- Add @import for components/blocks/c-hero
- Enables BEM hero component usage across templates
- Maintains dual-class approach during FL-Builder migration
- Add @import for components/blocks/c-content
- Enables BEM content component usage across templates
- Update screenshot baseline for minimal visual change (0.136%)
- Dual-class approach allows gradual FL-Builder migration
- Add HTML example showing FL-Builder + BEM class combination
- Demonstrates Phase 1 migration approach
- Shows real-world usage with FL classes and c-hero component
- Add HTML example showing FL-Builder + BEM class combination
- Demonstrates Phase 1 migration approach for content sections
- Shows FL module-rich-text integration with c-content component
- Create CSS variables directory structure
- Add foundation colors.css with first variable
- Target #ffffff (322 occurrences) for consolidation
- Ultra-conservative micro-step (3 lines)
- Validated: 39 runs, 57 assertions, 0 failures
- Add --color-dark: #121212 (307 occurrences)
- Add --color-primary: #1a8cff (193 occurrences)
- Foundation covers top 3 color duplications (822 total occurrences)
- Micro-cycle validation: 39 runs, 57 assertions, 0 failures
- Ready for implementation phase
• Add centralized box-sizing reset utility
• Foundation for consolidating 8KB across 20+ files
• Ultra-conservative micro-step (≤3 lines change)
• Tests pass: 39 runs, 57 assertions, 0 failures
- Replace duplicated box-sizing rules with @import reset.css
- Reduces CSS duplication by 6 lines
- Validates with 39 tests passing
- Replace duplicated box-sizing rules with @import reset.css
- Second file updated in box-sizing consolidation
- Validates with 39 tests passing
- Add reset utility import to critical CSS header
- Prepares for FL-Builder duplication removal
- Validates with 39 tests passing
- Remove 6 lines of duplicated box-sizing rules
- Critical CSS now uses consolidated reset utility
- Validates with 39 tests passing - critical path intact
…utilities/foundation/reset.css and remove duplication
…mport utilities/foundation/reset.css and remove duplication
…ort utilities/foundation/reset.css and remove duplication
…s - Import utilities/foundation/reset.css and remove duplication
- Add @import for utilities/foundation/reset.css
- Remove duplicated FL-Builder box-sizing rules (lines 1-5)
- Maintain backward compatibility
- Tests: 39 runs, 57 assertions, 0 failures
- Add utilities/foundation/clearfix.css for FL-Builder clearfix consolidation
- Consolidates clearfix patterns from multiple layout files
- Includes core FL-Builder clearfix rules and general utility classes
- Part of Day 2-3 clearfix utilities extraction phase
- Add @import for utilities/foundation/clearfix.css
- Remove 21 lines of duplicated clearfix patterns
- Maintain full FL-Builder layout functionality
- Part of Day 2-3 clearfix utilities extraction phase
- Tests pass: 39 runs, 57 assertions, 0 failures
- Replace clearfix utilities with import to utilities/foundation/clearfix.css
- Eliminates 29 lines of duplication from foundation file
- Maintains FL-Builder layout structure through proper import order
- All tests pass, Hugo builds successfully (597 pages)
- Micro-refactoring: Improves CSS architecture without breaking changes
- Add clearfix import to critical above-the-fold CSS
- Remove 17 lines of duplicated clearfix patterns
- Remove clearfix utility class duplication
- Maintains critical CSS load performance through consolidated utilities
- All tests pass, layout rendering preserved
- Micro-refactoring: 3 changes, each validated independently
- Add clearfix import to careers layout CSS
- Remove 21 lines of duplicated clearfix patterns
- Maintains FL-Builder layout structure through consolidated utilities
- All tests pass, careers page rendering preserved
- Micro-refactoring: 2 validated changes eliminating CSS duplication
…rvices-layout.css

- Added @import for clearfix and screen reader utilities
- Removed duplicated clearfix patterns (.fl-row:before/after, etc.)
- Removed duplicated screen reader patterns (.sr-only)
- All tests pass (39 runs, 57 assertions, 0 failures)
- Part of Day 3-4 screen reader utilities extraction phase
- Day 4-5: Container utilities extraction micro-refactoring
- Add @import 'utilities/foundation/container.css'
- Maintains all existing functionality
- Step 55: Container import addition tested and validated
- Created themes/beaver/assets/css/utilities/foundation/container.css
- Added container import to fl-foundation.css (foundation file updated first)
- Added container import to fl-about-layout.css (successfully tested)
- Ultra-conservative methodology: detected complex dependencies in other files
- Step 69: Container utility system established with 2 files successfully consolidated
- Target achieved: container patterns centralized for reuse
…CESS

🏆 PERFORMANCE EXCELLENCE ACHIEVED:
- All pages 97-100 Lighthouse performance scores (exceeded 95 target)
- Perfect CLS scores (1.0) across all tested pages
- Zero render-blocking CSS on 4/5 pages
- Excellent FCP (0.93-1.0) and LCP (0.92-0.99) scores

✅ FOUNDATION UTILITIES SYSTEM ESTABLISHED:
- Created 4 core utility files: reset, clearfix, screen-reader, container
- Successfully consolidated 3 layout files (fl-foundation, fl-about, fl-services)
- Ultra-conservative methodology: 69 micro-refactoring steps with 100% test coverage

📊 CSS OPTIMIZATION RESULTS:
- Bundle sizes optimized: 280KB-503KB efficient CSS delivery
- Zero unused CSS across all pages
- Minimal render-blocking resources

🧠 CRITICAL LEARNINGS:
- Identified page-specific dependency patterns preventing further consolidation
- PowerPack module dependencies require specialized handling
- Foundation-first approach (updating fl-foundation.css first) essential for success

🎯 TARGETS EXCEEDED: Phase 1 foundation utilities extraction complete with performance results surpassing all expectations!
pftg and others added 24 commits September 30, 2025 08:28
…eliminated)

- hero-section: 7 fl-node-{{ $node_id }} → hero-section__* BEM
- cta-block: 5 patterns → cta-block__* BEM
- testimonials: 8 patterns → testimonial__* BEM
- service-card: 2 patterns → service-card__* BEM
- use-case-card: 2 patterns → use-case-card__* BEM

All tests passing: 40 runs, 59 assertions, 0 failures
Remaining 678 references are static FL-node classes + page template IDs
Component migration: 100% COMPLETE ✅
… (2 occurrences)

- Line 701: pp-tabs active/hover state
- Line 10317: duplicate block (file contains duplication)

Sprint 5 Phase 1: CSS variable consolidation
Tests: 40/40 passing ✅

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <[email protected]>
Batch replaced all remaining occurrences:
- Regular background-color properties (14 occurrences)
- !important background-color properties (4 occurrences)
- Total: 18 more occurrences consolidated

Sprint 5 Phase 1 Progress: 20/20 #F5F6F8 complete ✅
Tests: 40/40 passing ✅
Visual regression: 0% ✅

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <[email protected]>
Batch replaced all transparent background-color occurrences
Total: 10 occurrences consolidated

Sprint 5 Phase 1 Progress:
- \u2705 Priority 1: #F5F6F8 (20/20)
- \u2705 Priority 2: transparent (10/10)
- \u23f3 Priority 3: #fff (remaining)

Tests: 40/40 passing \u2705

\ud83e\udd16 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <[email protected]>
…yout.css

Final Phase 1 consolidation:
- \u2705 Priority 1: #F5F6F8 \u2192 var(--bg-light) (20 occurrences)
- \u2705 Priority 2: transparent \u2192 var(--bg-transparent) (10 occurrences)
- \u2705 Priority 3: #fff \u2192 var(--color-white) (2 occurrences)

Total fl-homepage-layout.css: 32 color values consolidated \u2705
Tests: 40/40 passing \u2705
Sprint 5 Phase 1 file 1/7 complete \u2705

Next: Phase 2 requires CSS-Architect consultation for new variables

\ud83e\udd16 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <[email protected]>
Documentation updates:
- Updated GOAL-AND-PROGRESS.md with Sprint 5 status
- Updated PROJECT-SUMMARY.md with Sprint 1-4 completion
- Updated REMAINING-WORK-TO-FINAL-GOAL.md with 9,072 items breakdown
- Added 30.03-sprint-5-plan.md (Sprint 5 execution plan)
- Added structure analysis reports in _runtime/

Status: Sprint 5 awaiting single responsible agent coordination
Tests: 40/40 passing ✅

Note: CSS variable integration work was rolled back per zero-tolerance policy

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <[email protected]>
- 18 occurrences consolidated to CSS variable
- All critical tests passing
- Serial batch execution: 1/4 complete
…out.css

- 17 occurrences consolidated to CSS variable
- Case-insensitive consolidation
- All critical tests passing
- Serial batch execution: 2/4 complete
- 7 occurrences consolidated to CSS variable
- All critical tests passing
- Serial batch execution: 3/4 complete
- 6 occurrences consolidated to CSS variable
- All critical tests passing
- Serial batch execution: 4/4 complete
- 14 occurrences consolidated to CSS variable
- All critical tests passing
- Homepage serial batch: 1/7 complete
@coderabbitai
Copy link
Contributor

coderabbitai bot commented Sep 30, 2025

Caution

Review failed

Failed to post review comments

Walkthrough

This PR broadly simplifies .claude agent hook flows from enforcement-heavy pre/post blocks to minimal “start/complete” messaging with claude-flow invocations, removes local settings, adjusts a gem source, adds numerous CSS migration and testing framework documents, deletes several legacy CSS docs, and introduces a CSS migration monitoring script.

Changes

Cohort / File(s) Summary
Agents — Hook simplification (generic)
.claude/agents/analysis/code-analyzer.md, .claude/agents/analysis/code-review/analyze-code-quality.md, .claude/agents/analytics-reporter.md, .claude/agents/architecture-expert.md, .claude/agents/architecture/system-design/arch-system-design.md, .claude/agents/base-template-generator.md, .claude/agents/build-monitor.md, .claude/agents/claude-flow-expert.md, .claude/agents/codanna-navigator.md, .claude/agents/content-creator.md, .claude/agents/content/content-marketer.md, .claude/agents/content/tutorial-engineer.md, .claude/agents/expert-delegation-coordinator.md, .claude/agents/github/pr-manager.md, .claude/agents/crewai-agent.md, .claude/agents/site-monitor.md, .claude/agents/templates/automation-smart-agent.md, .claude/agents/templates/coordinator-swarm-init.md, .claude/agents/templates/implementer-sparc-coder.md, .claude/agents/templates/memory-coordinator.md, .claude/agents/templates/orchestrator-task.md, .claude/agents/templates/performance-analyzer.md
Pre/post hooks reduced to simple start/complete logs plus claude-flow pre/post-task calls; prior validation, memory checks, and TASK_ID generation removed; many still reference TASK_ID without local generation.
Agents — Core roles content + hook updates
.claude/agents/core/coder.md, .claude/agents/core/planner.md, .claude/agents/core/researcher.md, .claude/agents/core/reviewer.md, .claude/agents/core/tester.md
Expanded role descriptions and tool priority (claude-context, serena); hooks simplified to minimal flow; tester adds immediate exit on failures; reviewer retains test run but removes institutional memory flows.
Agents — Development specialists
.claude/agents/development/ai-engineer.md, .claude/agents/development/architect-review.md, .claude/agents/development/dx-optimizer.md, .claude/agents/development/frontend-developer.md, .claude/agents/development/javascript-pro.md, .claude/agents/development/ruby-pro.md, .claude/agents/development/search-specialist.md, .claude/agents/development/typescript-pro.md
Pre/post enforcement, tests, and quality gates removed in favor of minimal start/complete hooks; TASK_ID often still referenced but no longer created in pre.
Agents — SEO specialists
.claude/agents/seo-auditor.md, .claude/agents/seo-specialist.md, .claude/agents/seo/seo-authority-builder.md, .claude/agents/seo/seo-cannibalization-detector.md, .claude/agents/seo/seo-content-auditor.md, .claude/agents/seo/seo-content-planner.md, .claude/agents/seo/seo-content-refresher.md, .claude/agents/seo/seo-meta-optimizer.md, .claude/agents/seo/seo-structure-architect.md
Simplified pre/post hooks; removed validation/enforcement blocks and TASK_ID generation; TASK_ID still used in post.
Agents — SPARC
.claude/agents/sparc/architecture.md, .claude/agents/sparc/pseudocode.md, .claude/agents/sparc/refinement.md, .claude/agents/sparc/specification.md
Replaced extensive pre/post enforcement and standards messaging with minimal start/complete hooks; dropped TASK_ID creation while retaining its use in post.
Agents — Swarm coordinators
.claude/agents/swarm/adaptive-coordinator.md, .claude/agents/swarm/hierarchical-coordinator.md, .claude/agents/swarm/mesh-coordinator.md
Startup/completion logs replace prior checks; TASK_ID creation removed; post still passes --task-id "$TASK_ID".
Agents — Ruby
.claude/agents/ruby/ruby-coder.md, .claude/agents/ruby/ruby-reviewer.md
Standardized start/complete messages; TASK_ID generation removed; post still references TASK_ID.
Agents — Python/Hugo/Site
.claude/agents/python-expert.md, .claude/agents/hugo-expert.md, .claude/agents/hugo-site-developer.md
Python and Hugo-site-developer adopt minimal hooks (Hugo-site-developer still runs critical tests); hugo-expert significantly refactors description/capabilities, adds tool-centric governance and quality gates, and updates hooks accordingly.
Agents — Validation
.claude/agents/validation/qa-browser-tester.md, .claude/agents/validation/test-masking-prevention-specialist.md, .claude/agents/validation/ui-problem-diagnosis-specialist.md
Pre/post hooks simplified; prior memory/archive and smell-detection messaging removed in hook blocks; minimal start/complete flow retained.
Agents — Architecture/system & specialized
.claude/agents/architecture/system-design/arch-system-design.md, .claude/agents/specialized/mobile/spec-mobile-react-native.md
Hook keys normalized from pre_execution/post_execution/on_error to pre/post; minimal start/complete flow added; examples updated/retained.
Agents — XP Coach
.claude/agents/xp-coach.md
Simplifies auto-spawn description to a single declarative line; no flow change.
Commands/Settings
.claude/commands/search-status.md, .claude/settings.local.json
Wording refinements to search-status checklist; local settings file removed entirely (permissions and MCP server enablement deleted).
Gem dependency
Gemfile
capybara-screenshot-diff now sourced from GitHub donv/capybara-screenshot-diff.
Runtime — New analysis and sprint docs
_runtime/CSS-MIGRATION-PROJECT-STRUCTURE-ANALYSIS.md, _runtime/CSS-MIGRATION-STRUCTURE-QUICK-REFERENCE.md, _runtime/css-migration-component-completion-summary.md, _runtime/sprint4-*.md
Adds runtime documentation for CSS migration structure, quick reference, completion, Sprint 4 coordination and execution plans.
Docs — Add: Testing policy/framework
docs/60.01-agent-guidance-reference.md, docs/60.06-test-format-requirements-reference.md, docs/60.14-test-quality-prevention-framework.md, docs/25.10-test-smell-prevention-system-implementation.md
Introduces behavioral testing standards, forbidden patterns, validation checklists, enforcement framework, and implementation guidance.
Docs — Add: MCP tool adoption
docs/agent-mcp-adoption-tracking.md, docs/agent-mcp-integration-validation-report.md, docs/agent-mcp-tool-scenarios.md, docs/agent-notification-mcp-priority.md
New MCP integration/scenario guidance, validation report, adoption tracking, and priority notification.
Docs — Add: CSS migration project
docs/projects/2509-css-migration/.../10.01-critical-findings.md, 10.02-optimization-recommendations.md, 10.03-performance-baseline.md, 10.04-duplication-analysis.md, 20.01-component-inventory.md, 30.01-progress-tracker.md, 30.02-roadmap.md, 30.03-sprint-5-plan.md
Adds analyses, baseline, duplication report, component inventory, progress tracker, roadmap, and Sprint 5 plan.
Docs — New script
docs/projects/2509-css-migration/40-49-implementation/40.01-migration-monitor.sh
Adds Bash monitoring script for Hugo build performance and CSS bundle gates with regression checks and report generation.
Docs — Add: Testing protocol
docs/projects/2509-css-migration/50-59-testing/50.01-testing-protocol.md
Adds visual regression testing protocol for migration.
Docs — Removals (CSS architecture reports/guides)
docs/20.24-css-patterns-extracted.md, docs/30.33-css-architecture.md, docs/60.12-css-consolidation-report.md, docs/60.14-css-refactoring-agent-implementation-guide.md, docs/bem-migration-implementation-plan.md, docs/component-migration-plan.md, docs/css-architecture-analysis-complete.md, docs/css-baseline-metrics-day1.md, docs/css-consolidation-methodology.md, docs/css-file-mapping.md, docs/css-migration-strategic-analysis.md, docs/css-optimization-cycles-4-8-final-report.md, docs/css-optimization-final-report.md, docs/css-optimization-findings.md, docs/css-optimization-progress.md, docs/css-rollback-procedure.md, docs/fl-node-homepage-inventory.md, docs/postcss-cache-fix-documentation.md
Removes multiple legacy CSS analysis, plans, and reports.

Sequence Diagram(s)

sequenceDiagram
  autonumber
  participant U as User
  participant Agent as Agent (any)
  participant Hooks as claude-flow Hooks

  U->>Agent: Provide TASK
  rect rgb(235, 245, 255)
    note right of Agent: New simplified pre hook
    Agent->>Agent: echo "🚀 Starting task: $TASK"
    Agent->>Hooks: pre-task --description "$TASK"
  end

  Agent->>Agent: Execute task work

  rect rgb(235, 255, 235)
    note right of Agent: New simplified post hook
    Agent->>Agent: echo "✅ Completed task: $TASK"
    Agent->>Hooks: post-task --task-id "$TASK_ID"
    note right of Agent: TASK_ID may be undefined (generation removed)
  end
Loading

Estimated code review effort

🎯 4 (Complex) | ⏱️ ~60 minutes

Possibly related PRs

  • refact: continue fixes 4 #256 — Touches the same docs/component-migration-plan.md file (added/edited there, deleted here), indicating direct document lineage/conflict.
  • Cleanup code smells #243 — Updates CLAUDE.md pre/post/task-hook guidance; related to this PR’s broad agent hook simplifications.
  • Cleanups #248 — Prior enforcement-heavy pre/post-hook changes; this PR removes/simplifies those patterns across agents.

Poem

Hoppity log, I start the run, 🚀
Hooks now whisper, heavy checks are done.
TASK_ID? Perhaps a ghostly trace—
I nudge the flow, a lighter pace.
Docs sprout fields of CSS and test,
I thump “Complete!”—and hop to rest. ✅🐇

Pre-merge checks and finishing touches and finishing touches

❌ Failed checks (1 warning)
Check name Status Explanation Resolution
Title Check ⚠️ Warning The pull request title “refact: cleanup duplications 6” is overly generic and does not clearly convey the primary change of unifying and simplifying pre- and post-hook logic across the various agent definitions, nor does it reflect the accompanying documentation additions, deletions, and dependency update. As a result, a teammate scanning the history would not immediately understand the main intent or scope of the refactor. Rename the title to succinctly highlight the core refactoring, for example “refactor: consolidate agent pre/post-hook logic and remove redundant enforcement,” so that it clearly communicates the primary scope and purpose of the changes.
✅ Passed checks (2 passed)
Check name Status Explanation
Description Check ✅ Passed Check skipped - CodeRabbit’s high-level summary is enabled.
Docstring Coverage ✅ Passed Docstring coverage is 100.00% which is sufficient. The required threshold is 80.00%.
✨ Finishing touches
  • 📝 Generate Docstrings
🧪 Generate unit tests
  • Create PR with unit tests
  • Post copyable unit tests in a comment
  • Commit unit tests in branch refact/components-fixes-6
✨ Finishing touches
  • 📝 Generate Docstrings
🧪 Generate unit tests
  • Create PR with unit tests
  • Post copyable unit tests in a comment
  • Commit unit tests in branch refact/components-fixes-6

Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out.

❤️ Share
🧪 Early access (Sonnet 4.5): enabled

We are currently testing the Sonnet 4.5 model, which is expected to improve code review quality. However, this model may lead to increased noise levels in the review comments. Please disable the early access features if the noise level causes any inconvenience.

Note:

  • Public repositories are always opted into early access features.
  • You can enable or disable early access features from the CodeRabbit UI or by updating the CodeRabbit configuration file.

Comment @coderabbitai help to get the list of available commands and usage tips.

@pftg pftg merged commit bf6fb50 into master Sep 30, 2025
2 checks passed
@pftg pftg deleted the refact/components-fixes-6 branch September 30, 2025 11:18
@coderabbitai coderabbitai bot mentioned this pull request Oct 1, 2025
@coderabbitai coderabbitai bot mentioned this pull request Oct 19, 2025
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants