Skip to content

Fix #63: mark unimplemented features as planned in README#98

Open
polishfreak wants to merge 1 commit intoodgrim:mainfrom
polishfreak:fix-issue-63
Open

Fix #63: mark unimplemented features as planned in README#98
polishfreak wants to merge 1 commit intoodgrim:mainfrom
polishfreak:fix-issue-63

Conversation

@polishfreak
Copy link
Contributor

Summary

  • Adds (planned) markers to Agent evolution and Meta-planning bullet points in the "What it does" section
  • Adds a Roadmap section before Contributing that clearly distinguishes implemented vs planned features

Fixes

Closes #63

Changes

README.md — 2 bullet edits + 1 new section (11 insertions, 2 deletions)

- Add (planned) markers to Agent evolution and Meta-planning bullets
- Add Roadmap section distinguishing implemented vs planned features
@polishfreak
Copy link
Contributor Author

tried to do with llama 3.1 8gb... Claude code moved it :(

Copy link
Owner

@odgrim odgrim left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Review: Marking features as planned — incorrect premise

Issue

This PR marks Agent evolution and Meta-planning as (planned), but both features are actually implemented:

  • src/services/evolution_loop.rs1,229 lines implementing success rate tracking, template refinement triggering, auto-reversion on regression, and rolling window evaluation
  • src/services/meta_planner.rs416 lines implementing task analysis, capability gap detection, and specialist agent spawning

These are substantial, working implementations — not stubs or placeholders.

What to do instead

The original issue (#63) was filed based on a surface-level grep that missed the actual implementations. The issue itself should be closed as "not a bug" rather than addressed by incorrectly marking working features as planned.

I'm rejecting this PR because merging it would make the README less accurate, not more.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Documentation: README mentions 'agent evolution' and 'meta-planning' as features but these appear unimplemented

2 participants