Conversation
|
IMPORTANT: when we merge this, I think our pyOSMeta build MIGHT break on these issues. We will want to update the model to include Genai tools used as a start, and we may need to increase the lines of hte template that are parsed. |
|
This is failing because of all-contributors which we are working on now. so we can ignore that failure for now until the new urls are sorted out. |
|
|
||
| - [ ] This package has a public development history spanning 3-6 months, with commits distributed over time that reflect **iterative, thoughtful development.** | ||
| - [ ] All code in this package has been **carefully reviewed by a human**. Its implementation is also understood by the authors submitting the package. | ||
| - [ ] All communication on this issue will be written by a human (someone on your maintainer team). We embrace the use of LLMs for translation and grammar correction. We prefer honest interactions over ones that prioritize perfect language and grammar. As little aid from a LLM as possible. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Can we shorten this? OR we can link to more about this. perhaps remove the translation piece
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I'd keep this as-is. There was a decent chunk of folks who didn't look at links present, this forces acknowledgement.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@coatless Does Leah's version below look ok to you? Still includes the bit about communication written by human, but links to our peer-review guide for the translation details.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Sure; but, I'll revoice that the more links present across multiple guides the less likely the submitters are going to go to them. Again, these are built-in to the template meaning that unless they copy & paste the URL to visit or switch to preview mode and click it's highly unlikely that these documents will be reviewed.
|
|
||
| - [ ] This package has a public development history spanning 3-6 months, with commits distributed over time that reflect **iterative, thoughtful development.** | ||
| - [ ] All code in this package has been **carefully reviewed by a human**. Its implementation is also understood by the authors submitting the package. | ||
| - [ ] All communication on this issue will be written by a human (someone on your maintainer team). We embrace the use of LLMs for translation and grammar correction. We prefer honest interactions over ones that prioritize perfect language and grammar. As little aid from a LLM as possible. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
| - [ ] All communication on this issue will be written by a human (someone on your maintainer team). We embrace the use of LLMs for translation and grammar correction. We prefer honest interactions over ones that prioritize perfect language and grammar. As little aid from a LLM as possible. | |
| - [ ] All communication on this issue will be written by a human (someone on your maintainer team). [See more](llms & translation) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Link to section in guide on translation and communication
|
|
||
| ### If you have a policy around generative AI use in your project, please provide a link to it below: | ||
|
|
||
| - _Your link here (remove this line if you don't have a link)_ |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
| - _Your link here (remove this line if you don't have a link)_ | |
| _[Your link here](foo.com) (remove this line if you don't have a link)_ |
| [Read our full generative ai policy here.](https://www.pyopensci.org/software-peer-review/our-process/policies.html#disclosure-of-generative-ai-use-in-pyopensci-reviewed-packages) | ||
| - [ ] This package has a public development history spanning 3-6 months, with commits distributed over time that reflect **iterative, thoughtful development.** | ||
| - [ ] All code in this package has been **carefully reviewed by a human**. Its implementation is also understood by the authors submitting the package. | ||
| - [ ] All communication on this issue will be written by a human (someone on your maintainer team). We embrace the use of LLMs for translation and grammar correction. We prefer honest interactions over ones that prioritize perfect language and grammar. As little aid from a LLM as possible. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
| - [ ] All communication on this issue will be written by a human (someone on your maintainer team). We embrace the use of LLMs for translation and grammar correction. We prefer honest interactions over ones that prioritize perfect language and grammar. As little aid from a LLM as possible. | |
| - [ ] All communication on this issue will be written by a human (someone on your maintainer team). [Learn more]() |
4 participants
This PR takes the work we did here:
and turns it into a few check boxes in our issue template. This will then be complemented by a second pr to the peer review guide around new policies.