Skip to content
Open
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
10 changes: 5 additions & 5 deletions _posts/2014-08-22-chickens-and-pigs.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -32,20 +32,20 @@ Textbooks are not just expensive, they're usualy terrible. If they were great, t

### terrible textbooks

The mechanism behind terrible textbooks is the same mechanism behind terrible enterprise software. In my experience, enterprise software can be effective when selected by people who don't have to use it. The key is whether it is selected by pigs. People who have to use it are one kind of pig. People accountable for the productivity it deleivers are another kind of pig. As long as an enterprise software project is driven by pigs and the chickens are restricted to an advisory capacity, you can have effective software.
The mechanism behind terrible textbooks is the same mechanism behind terrible enterprise software. In my experience, enterprise software can't be effective when selected by people who don't have to use it. The key is whether it is selected by pigs. People who have to use it are one kind of pig. People accountable for the productivity it deleivers are another kind of pig. As long as an enterprise software project is driven by pigs and the chickens are restricted to an advisory capacity, you can have effective software.

But even one chicken with direct management authority or veto power can ruin an enterprise project: They "coattail" requirements that suit their own objectives at the expense of the project's success, and you end up with nonsense. (This happens everywhere. Microsoft is suffering now because its "cash cows," Windows and Office, behaved like chickens on steriods for decades, making almost every other division and department subordinate to their goals.)

So about textbooks. It's fairly obvious that the problem with textbook quality and price is that the students are pigs and everyone else--faculty, adminsitartion, publishers--are chickens with authority. Fixing this problem could be done by routing around the whole system. For example, make universities irrelevant.
So about textbooks. It's fairly obvious that the problem with textbook quality and price is that the students are pigs and everyone else--faculty, adminstration, publishers--are chickens with authority. Fixing this problem could be done by routing around the whole system. For example, make universities irrelevant.

### why we are about chickens and pigs

Regardless of what we do or do not do with textbooks, we should always pay attention to the chickens and pigs dynamic. It's an enormously indsidious pheneomenon, and wherever you find it, you find waste and human misery.
Regardless of what we do or do not do with textbooks, we should always pay attention to the chickens and pigs dynamic. It's an enormously insidious phenomenon, and wherever you find it, you find waste and human misery.

Which also means, wherever you find it, there are opportunities to make money *and* to make people's lives better. If you figure out how to disrupt textbooks, you're cracking a billion dollar market, *and* helping people get an affordable education. If you figure out how to help enterprise software developers work together, better, you're cracking another billion dollar market and again making people happy doing something they love.

So in conlusion... Textbooks are an example of the chicken and egg dynamic. It's an important dynamic to understand, because it is very common, *and* if you can crack it, you can make money while making people's lives better.
So in conclusion... Textbooks are an example of the chicken and egg dynamic. It's an important dynamic to understand, because it is very common, *and* if you can crack it, you can make money while making people's lives better.

Which reminds me of another thing I once read:

> "Where there's muck, there's brass."—Paul Graham
> "Where there's muck, there's brass."—Paul Graham