Conversation
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Greptile Summary
This PR implements a deprecation strategy for the state_auto_setters configuration option, which currently defaults to True and automatically generates setter methods for state variables. The changes introduce a three-phase deprecation approach:
-
Configuration Change: The
state_auto_settersfield inreflex/config.pyis changed frombool = Truetobool | None = None, makingNonethe new default value. -
Logic Update: In
reflex/state.py, the condition for creating automatic setters is updated fromget_config().state_auto_setterstoget_config().state_auto_setters is not False. This ensures that when the config isNone(the new default), setters are still created to maintain backward compatibility. -
Deprecation Warning: In
reflex/vars/base.py, a new deprecation warning is added to the_get_settermethod. Whenstate_auto_settersisNone(indicating users haven't explicitly configured it), the system issues a warning indicating that the default behavior will change fromTruetoFalsein version 0.9.0. -
Enhanced Frame Detection: The deprecation warning system in
reflex/utils/console.pyis improved with better frame detection logic to more accurately identify user code vs framework code when issuing warnings. This includes excluding Python standard library modules and additional third-party frameworks from the warning context.
This deprecation follows standard software engineering practices: warn users about the upcoming change while maintaining current functionality, giving them time to either explicitly set state_auto_setters=True to keep current behavior or state_auto_setters=False to opt into the new default.
Confidence score: 4/5
- This PR implements a well-structured deprecation strategy with minimal risk of breaking existing functionality
- Score reflects the thorough approach to backward compatibility and clear migration path provided to users
- Pay close attention to the frame detection logic in console.py to ensure deprecation warnings appear in the correct context
4 files reviewed, 2 comments
CodSpeed Performance ReportMerging #5739 will not alter performanceComparing Summary
|
* move state_auth_setters deprecation warning to compile time * Also warn for setvar
|
Hi there |
No description provided.